What's new

Comparative analysis . Pakistan exports CY ( Jan - Dec). REER value of pkr. Remittances.

Patriot forever

SENIOR MEMBER
Jun 2, 2020
3,338
5
7,254
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
A comparative analysis at a basic level.

a) Exports CY basis (Jan-Dec)


Our exports dropped as the result of lack of competitiveness which ultimately led to erosion of capacity. (CY20 is when corona hit).
FJYwSGmX0AQ3bRI.jpeg


b) REER value of currency.

From a fairly valued currency in 2013 which should have been maintained SBP interference in currency began ( the longetivity of period clearly shows that it was done as a policy decision by political interference in SBP operations).

FJHxIWYXwAM77tc.jpeg


c) Remittances.

For 4 years from FY 2014 - FY 2018 our remittances inflows were stagnant and the natural growth momentum/trajectory was subdued due to artificial manipulation of currency.

images (3).jpeg



During the same 5 year period India and Bangladesh enhanced their exports by roughly 50%, making their currency and macros fundamentally strong.
 

Norwegian

ELITE MEMBER
Aug 19, 2014
17,746
10
28,774
Country
Israel
Location
Norway
b) REER value of currency.

From a fairly valued currency in 2013 which should have been maintained SBP interference in currency began ( the longetivity of period clearly shows that it was done as a policy decision by political interference in SBP operations).
Why don't you name the culprit of this political interference that destroyed Pakistani exports competitiveness for 5 long years? Shouldn't Pmln cheerleaders be called out shamed in public for this policy disaster? Shouldn't they be held responsible for the current economic crisis because there was zero export growth during Pmln years despite 5,6 recorded gdp growth?
C1945423-24E9-4F96-B215-553738CE8F45.jpeg


@FOOLS_NIGHTMARE @Tameem @muhammadhafeezmalik @Chak Bamu @Mav3rick @Pakistan Space Agency @Wood
 

ziaulislam

ELITE MEMBER
Apr 22, 2010
18,116
10
18,785
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
Why don't you name the culprit of this political interference that destroyed Pakistani exports competitiveness for 5 long years? Shouldn' Pmln cheerleaders be called out shamed in public for this policy disaster? Shouldn't they be held responsible for the current economic crisis because there was zero export growth during Pmln years despite 5,6 recorded gdp growth?
View attachment 809698

@FOOLS_NIGHTMARE @Tameem @muhammadhafeezmalik @Chak Bamu @Mav3rick @Pakistan Space Agency @Wood


Screenshot_20220112-052726_Twitter.jpg

A comparative analysis at a basic level.

a) Exports CY basis (Jan-Dec)


Our exports dropped as the result of lack of competitiveness which ultimately led to erosion of capacity. (CY20 is when corona hit).
View attachment 809625

b) REER value of currency.

From a fairly valued currency in 2013 which should have been maintained SBP interference in currency began ( the longetivity of period clearly shows that it was done as a policy decision by political interference in SBP operations).

View attachment 809624

c) Remittances.

For 4 years from FY 2014 - FY 2018 our remittances inflows were stagnant and the natural growth momentum/trajectory was subdued due to artificial manipulation of currency.

View attachment 809626


During the same 5 year period India and Bangladesh enhanced their exports by roughly 50%, making their currency and macros fundamentally strong.
 

muhammadhafeezmalik

SENIOR MEMBER
Jan 21, 2015
2,257
-6
2,110
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Why don't you name the culprit of this political interference that destroyed Pakistani exports competitiveness for 5 long years? Shouldn't Pmln cheerleaders be called out shamed in public for this policy disaster? Shouldn't they be held responsible for the current economic crisis because there was zero export growth during Pmln years despite 5,6 recorded gdp growth?
View attachment 809698

@FOOLS_NIGHTMARE @Tameem @muhammadhafeezmalik @Chak Bamu @Mav3rick @Pakistan Space Agency @Wood

Vision of selected economists!!

 
Last edited:

Chak Bamu

RETIRED MOD
Jan 3, 2013
5,364
69
10,186
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Why don't you name the culprit of this political interference that destroyed Pakistani exports competitiveness for 5 long years? Shouldn't Pmln cheerleaders be called out shamed in public for this policy disaster? Shouldn't they be held responsible for the current economic crisis because there was zero export growth during Pmln years despite 5,6 recorded gdp growth?

@FOOLS_NIGHTMARE @Tameem @muhammadhafeezmalik @Chak Bamu @Mav3rick @Pakistan Space Agency @Wood
Why am I tagged here?
 

crankthatskunk

SENIOR MEMBER
May 20, 2011
5,329
5
10,017
Country
United Kingdom
Location
United Kingdom
Why don't you name the culprit of this political interference that destroyed Pakistani exports competitiveness for 5 long years? Shouldn't Pmln cheerleaders be called out shamed in public for this policy disaster? Shouldn't they be held responsible for the current economic crisis because there was zero export growth during Pmln years despite 5,6 recorded gdp growth?
View attachment 809698

@FOOLS_NIGHTMARE @Tameem @muhammadhafeezmalik @Chak Bamu @Mav3rick @Pakistan Space Agency @Wood

Pakistani people who are not very educated do not understand how Dar caused damage to Pakistan. I am saying for last 8 years, he should be publicly hanged. This man is by nature a criminal. If any in doubt, he accepted that he opened fake bank accounts on the names of the members of Qazi family after having access to their passports. Opening bank accounts on somebody;'s name using their stolen IDs is a criminal offence, admitted by this criminal.
If you make a known and confessed criminal your finance minister, do not expect him to act differently.

The flip side of keeping the rupee artificially low against dollar, the imports look cheaper and attractive. That's what happened the imports soared, and exports were stagnant resulting in huge trade deficit. I challenged, any PMLN supporter or stupid Pakistani journalists to prove in what sector Pakistan progressed during PMLN era!!

PMLN just create illusions with the help of corrupt Pakistani media, which have nothing to do with reality.
Dar hidden debts from the figures to keep rupee strong and thrown billions in the market to keep the rupee strong, so his crimes are multi facet , Pakistanis should realise them.
 

S.Y.A

SENIOR MEMBER
Mar 21, 2008
3,316
2
3,692
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Pakistani people who are not very educated do not understand how Dar caused damage to Pakistan. I am saying for last 8 years, he should be publicly hanged. This man is by nature a criminal. If any in doubt, he accepted that he opened fake bank accounts on the names of the members of Qazi family after having access to their passports. Opening bank accounts on somebody;'s name using their stolen IDs is a criminal offence, admitted by this criminal.
If you make a known and confessed criminal your finance minister, do not expect him to act differently.

The flip side of keeping the rupee artificially low against dollar, the imports look cheaper and attractive. That's what happened the imports soared, and exports were stagnant resulting in huge trade deficit. I challenged, any PMLN supporter or stupid Pakistani journalists to prove in what sector Pakistan progressed during PMLN era!!

PMLN just create illusions with the help of corrupt Pakistani media, which have nothing to do with reality.
Dar hidden debts from the figures to keep rupee strong and thrown billions in the market to keep the rupee strong, so his crimes are multi facet , Pakistanis should realise them.
I have tried to explain this to many people, even my subordinates, all of them have only one answer, even after listening to everything: "ghareeb khush tha, sab sasta tha". And now, the ghareeb doesnt understand that you have to pay for that sasta maal.

I am against the policy of increasing/imposing GST though. direct taxation should and must be increased, FBR should be proactive, but that is asking a lot from an organization who is stuck in 20th century.

no-tax slabs should be abolished, and tax rates slightly raised, its better for a person earning even a few thousand rupees to pay 10% one time directly to govt, rather than paying 17% again and again to retailers and companies who under-declare their sales.
 
Last edited:

ziaulislam

ELITE MEMBER
Apr 22, 2010
18,116
10
18,785
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
Pakistani people who are not very educated do not understand how Dar caused damage to Pakistan. I am saying for last 8 years, he should be publicly hanged. This man is by nature a criminal. If any in doubt, he accepted that he opened fake bank accounts on the names of the members of Qazi family after having access to their passports. Opening bank accounts on somebody;'s name using their stolen IDs is a criminal offence, admitted by this criminal.
If you make a known and confessed criminal your finance minister, do not expect him to act differently.

The flip side of keeping the rupee artificially low against dollar, the imports look cheaper and attractive. That's what happened the imports soared, and exports were stagnant resulting in huge trade deficit. I challenged, any PMLN supporter or stupid Pakistani journalists to prove in what sector Pakistan progressed during PMLN era!!

PMLN just create illusions with the help of corrupt Pakistani media, which have nothing to do with reality.
Dar hidden debts from the figures to keep rupee strong and thrown billions in the market to keep the rupee strong, so his crimes are multi facet , Pakistanis should realise them.
And i am saying its not dar fault
He does what public tells him to do

Public wants to live like this..life is short ..awaam ko relief chaya

So do want hang crore people ?

Why don't you name the culprit of this political interference that destroyed Pakistani exports competitiveness for 5 long years? Shouldn't Pmln cheerleaders be called out shamed in public for this policy disaster? Shouldn't they be held responsible for the current economic crisis because there was zero export growth during Pmln years despite 5,6 recorded gdp growth?
View attachment 809698

@FOOLS_NIGHTMARE @Tameem @muhammadhafeezmalik @Chak Bamu @Mav3rick @Pakistan Space Agency @Wood
There was export decline
But biggest disaster was lack of saving(hence lowest tax to gdp saving/investment) due to very low interest rates(savings halfed)

His screw up was so bad that saving havent returned up and govt still is striggling to get it up
 

crankthatskunk

SENIOR MEMBER
May 20, 2011
5,329
5
10,017
Country
United Kingdom
Location
United Kingdom
And i am saying its not dar fault
He does what public tells him to do

Public wants to live like this..life is short ..awaam ko relief chaya

So do want hang crore people ?


There was export decline
But biggest disaster was lack of saving(hence lowest tax to gdp saving/investment) due to very low interest rates(savings halfed)

His screw up was so bad that saving havent returned up and govt still is striggling to get it up

So Dar was there to "Aam chupan"!!

Public never asked anything from Dar. He fudged the figures, he borrowed on private companies names, hidden the debts. Show one evidence public asked him that!!
He ruined Pakistan, he is a traitor and proven criminal, read his statement to the magistrate, he accepted all his crimes.
 

ziaulislam

ELITE MEMBER
Apr 22, 2010
18,116
10
18,785
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
So Dar was there to "Aam chupan"!!

Public never asked anything from Dar. He fudged the figures, he borrowed on private companies names, hidden the debts. Show one evidence public asked him that!!
He ruined Pakistan, he is a traitor and proven criminal, read his statement to the magistrate, he accepted all his crimes.
And people say its okay
You will see that in 2023

Dont parents gorgive their kids and defend them all the time

We love nawaz sharif so we will defend anything
Same way some people love zardari and imran khan
 

Warking

FULL MEMBER
Aug 12, 2021
188
0
181
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
And people say its okay
You will see that in 2023

Dont parents gorgive their kids and defend them all the time

We love nawaz sharif so we will defend anything
Same way some people love zardari and imran khan
I don't "Love" any leader unconditionally no leader should be loved unconditionally.
 

crankthatskunk

SENIOR MEMBER
May 20, 2011
5,329
5
10,017
Country
United Kingdom
Location
United Kingdom
And people say its okay
You will see that in 2023

Dont parents gorgive their kids and defend them all the time

We love nawaz sharif so we will defend anything
Same way some people love zardari and imran khan

No, you are anyone else has no right to forgive the criminals, without them facing the sentences for their crimes.
 

ziaulislam

ELITE MEMBER
Apr 22, 2010
18,116
10
18,785
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
No, you are anyone else has no right to forgive the criminals, without them facing the sentences for their crimes.
People of pakistan have the right
And they have forgiven leaders several times since 1980s

Nawaz sharif and benazir corruption was well known in 1990s
They are still elected

کیوں کہ کھاتا ہے تو لگاتا بی ہے
 

crankthatskunk

SENIOR MEMBER
May 20, 2011
5,329
5
10,017
Country
United Kingdom
Location
United Kingdom
People of pakistan have the right
And they have forgiven leaders several times since 1980s

Nawaz sharif and benazir corruption was well known in 1990s
They are still elected

کیوں کہ کھاتا ہے تو لگاتا بی ہے

Yeah, because of people like you, they are still committing crimes.
Forgiveness is futile without criminal repents, which Sharif never did.
That's why I always said that Musharaf and Kiyani should have been Court Martial for designing and implementing NRO They have no rights to forgives nation's sinners.
Un ke baap ka paisa nahi tha.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)


Top Bottom