What's new

Cabinet Committee On Security Clears Purchase Of 83 Tejas Mark-1A Fighters For Indian Air Force

Feraro

FULL MEMBER

New Recruit

Dec 27, 2020
8
0
16
Country
India
Location
India
so no further Rafales ?
The Rafale is in different category vis-a-vis the Tejas. One is a point defence fighter which is gaining additional capabilites. And the other is a twin engine medium heavy multi role fighter.

One cannot replace the other. Each have their own role to play.
 

Feraro

FULL MEMBER

New Recruit

Dec 27, 2020
8
0
16
Country
India
Location
India
Sorry to burst your bubble but there is no such fighter called MK1A it exists on paper only not a single prototype has flown yet ...... if it is approved that means a prototype will be made integration of new systems will take time .... JF17 block 3 made its first flight in Dec 2019 and in Dec 2020 we have officially started production that means it took 1 year to test certify and Integrate weapons.... how long will it take for MK1A remains to be seen although historically tejas is always years behind JF17 so expect half a squadron of MK1A by 2025 if you're lucky... by that time Pakistan will either stop producing JF17 or block 4 will arrive..
I give respect to your view but they are misguided.
There is almost nil change in the airframe of both the Tejas mk1 and Tejas mk1a.
The FCS remains the same. There will be no need for extensive retesting. Already simulation studies have been done to validate changes. Changes like the External Jammer Pod, Israeli AESA radar, IFR etc have already been validated on Lsp aircraft.
Little work remains to be done.

The first Tejas mk1a is expected to be delivered in 3 years after contract signature. HAL was waiting for confirmation of the orders before starting the process.

On the other hand the Tejas mk2 or the MWF is almost a new aircraft.
 

Feraro

FULL MEMBER

New Recruit

Dec 27, 2020
8
0
16
Country
India
Location
India
Lmao replace trolls with indians as they are the spoilers here 🤣

Mate we have been hearing this for years that india has upped the production speed and capacity but in 2020 number made were 6...

Atleast he spoke truth unlike indian defence geeks saying 100% indian 🤣
Janab, I am sure you are not a racist who hates all Indians.
Let us try to have a civil discussion based on reason and merits.

The recent conflict with China has shaken up the bureaucracy in India.
Defence is being taken more seriously. I am optimistic.

I guarantee you that you will hear more defence acquisition news coming from India.
Come on yaar he isn't start trolling yet, lets be sane and not expect this new indian guy is a troller
Deeply honoured by your generosity.
Come on bro. Take it easy. I gather we are all learned and moderate people who can have a civil discussion.
 
Last edited:

airomerix

PDF THINK TANK: ANALYST
Dec 31, 2012
1,574
34
6,598
Country
United Kingdom
Location
Canada
What is interesting is, IAF spent years negotiating the price that was quoted at Rs.50,000 cr to Rs. 39,000 cr. In the end they're paying Rs.48,000 cr that equates to $80 million per aircraft. Whats also interesting is the reduction in capex of IAF for 2020-2021. Factoring in the HAL's track record, the project timeline will be possibly pushed further by at least 3 years, considering the budget cuts and plans for 'two front war' by Bipin, where he is planning on raising dedicated new divisions on the northern front.

I sense chest thumping.

EPsCm7_VAAU1gxb.jpeg
 

FairAndUnbiased

SENIOR MEMBER
Nov 25, 2011
7,170
0
10,619
Country
China
Location
United States
One vital difference between the two aircraft is that the systems that we have sourced from Israel, US, France etc are generally accepted to be better than equivalent Chinese components. So we are producing an aircraft with better systems. I wish to remind you that China requested and received know how from Israel on their Lavi fighter. Obviously if they did not feel that the Israelis had superior technology they would never have asked Israel for help. Similarly they wanted to buy Israeli Phalcon AWACS, a deal which Washington vetoed. I hope you don't deny these transactions to score a petty point. Please research the truth of my assertions.
proof? there is documented proof that the J-10 was developed from the J-9 tech demonstrator.

In addition there is proof that there is no possible design connection between Lavi and J-10: Lavi has a rounded inlet, which has vastly different aerodynamics than the rectangular J-10 inlet. In addition the J-10 is 20% heavier than the Lavi, 20% faster and has a different weight distribution.

If just being visually similar is enough, then anyone can build a Boeing 737. But they can't because every part of it is finely tuned to within single % levels. 20% change is gigantic to a plane.

China is also one of the most innovative countries in patents per capita (a measure that India doesn't even show up on because it is so far behind), so it doesn' t even make sense that China needs a fighter from someone else.
 

Feraro

FULL MEMBER

New Recruit

Dec 27, 2020
8
0
16
Country
India
Location
India
proof? there is documented proof that the J-10 was developed from the J-9 tech demonstrator.

In addition there is proof that there is no possible design connection between Lavi and J-10: Lavi has a rounded inlet, which has vastly different aerodynamics than the rectangular J-10 inlet. In addition the J-10 is 20% heavier than the Lavi, 20% faster and has a different weight distribution.

If just being visually similar is enough, then anyone can build a Boeing 737. But they can't because every part of it is finely tuned to within single % levels. 20% change is gigantic to a plane.

China is also one of the most innovative countries in patents per capita (a measure that India doesn't even show up on because it is so far behind), so it doesn' t even make sense that China needs a fighter from someone else.
I think you are digressing. We are here to discuss the Tejas.
Comparison between the Lavi and the J10 is another matter.
But truth is the Chinese and the Israelis did have some sort of collaboration in the past.
Let's leave it at that.
 

pothead

SENIOR MEMBER
Jun 18, 2017
3,959
-14
2,895
Country
India
Location
Germany
Oh dear almighty Bhagavan.

Do few "geniuses" here really think there is an aircraft in the world with 100% indigenization?

May be these "geniuses" can provide examples.
 

FairAndUnbiased

SENIOR MEMBER
Nov 25, 2011
7,170
0
10,619
Country
China
Location
United States
I think you are digressing. We are here to discuss the Tejas.
Comparison between the Lavi and the J10 is another matter.
But truth is the Chinese and the Israelis did have some sort of collaboration in the past.
Let's leave it at that.
The problem with Tejas is that it has too many suppliers and it doesn't have a clear role.

Low cost single engine fighter that's fast to build? Costs more than F-16 and J-10, has multiple foreign suppliers. In a hot war you can't build it fast due to long shipping time and high coordination requirements. End result: logistical nightmare

Agile dogfighter? Poor 6 oclock visibility due to the canopy being set too low in the airframe.

BVR? Worse than Su-30 in every way: low range, small nose for radar, low payload (half that of the F-16 or J-10).

As far as I can see, the sole selling point of the Tejas is that it is assembled in India. It literally does not have an advantage in any other way over any other existing aircraft available to India.
 
Oct 29, 2020
1,406
0
717
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
Nowadays most combat aircraft rely on components and systems supply from multiple vendors spread across the world. We have as a temporary measure sourced certain systems and sub systems from countries like the US, Israel etc. This is till we manage to indigenise the production of these items.

Yes both the Tejas and the JF17 have many parts from suppliers outside. Though I will take the liberty of stating that there are far more Indian manufactured components in the Tejas than there are Pakistan manufactured components in the JF17.

I know you will immediately contest this. Maybe to support your view you can list out the Pakistan made components of the JF17 and the list can be compared to the list of Indian made components in the Tejas.

One vital difference between the two aircraft is that the systems that we have sourced from Israel, US, France etc are generally accepted to be better than equivalent Chinese components. So we are producing an aircraft with better systems. I wish to remind you that China requested and received know how from Israel on their Lavi fighter. Obviously if they did not feel that the Israelis had superior technology they would never have asked Israel for help. Similarly they wanted to buy Israeli Phalcon AWACS, a deal which Washington vetoed. I hope you don't deny these transactions to score a petty point. Please research the truth of my assertions.

Lastly I don't expect India to be embargoed by the suppliers of the said components for the Tejas. We have extremely friendly relations with Israel, France and the US. And anyway we are progressively indigenising the imported components. Example is the Uttam AESA radar which will replace the Israeli Elta 2052 radar. The Uttam AESA radar is already installed in an Lsp Tejas aircraft and has successfully passed various air to air operating modes.
its not true about combat aircraft but airliners follows that traits, yes few exception and example are there look dude, all 5th gen jets projects that currently in the progress from third world countries and some first world countries like South Korea/India/Turkey/China/Russia/Japan./Indonesia are going through help of US/China/EU because these countries are not able to develop some or most of technologies necessary to develop 5th gen jets and as well as to reduce the project cost, prime example of that F-35 project but this not for US can't build F-35 from it own but 2 reduce project cost
 
Last edited:

Deino

INT'L MOD
Nov 9, 2014
9,666
14
15,374
Country
Germany
Location
Germany
Wonderful... finally this was cleared. First few MK1A's are already on the production floor and may be ready in no time. With HAL ramping up the production rate it will be much quicker.

But the game changer will be AMCA for me.... hope we hear some good news on that front.

Really ,,, so sorry, in case I missed it, but when can we realistically expect to see the first Mk.1A and even more the first Mk.2?
 

drumstick

FULL MEMBER
Feb 17, 2020
881
-17
612
Country
India
Location
India
Really ,,, so sorry, in case I missed it, but when can we realistically expect to see the first Mk.1A and even more the first Mk.2?
good that you are sorry for missing such an important event.

deliveries are expected from 18th month... first MK2 stay tunes on this forum...
 

TheSnakeEatingMarkhur

FULL MEMBER
Dec 26, 2018
1,217
0
1,129
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Kingdom
Janab, I am sure you are not a racist who hates all Indians.
Let us try to have a civil discussion based on reason and merits.

The recent conflict with China has shaken up the bureaucracy in India.
Defence is being taken more seriously. I am optimistic.

I guarantee you that you will hear more defence acquisition news coming from India.
Indians are not a race so hating em wouldnt make it a case of racism... but I dont hate all indians I only hate "andhbhakts"
 

Deino

INT'L MOD
Nov 9, 2014
9,666
14
15,374
Country
Germany
Location
Germany
good that you are sorry for missing such an important event.

deliveries are expected from 18th month... first MK2 stay tunes on this forum...

Pardon ... 18th month means what? The 18th month that does not exist, so in fact never? :omghaha:
Or the 18th of a certain month?
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 2, Members: 0, Guests: 2)


Top Bottom