What's new

As a non-white, can anyone tell me why Europe and the United States defended Australia’s killing of civilians?

FuturePAF

SENIOR MEMBER
Dec 17, 2014
3,857
19
4,767
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
As long as a normal human being, it is known that the slaughter of civilians is a crime, is not allowed by international law, and is a war crime.
The Australian government recognizes the criminal behavior of Australian soldiers, and the Australian media also criticizes these soldiers.
But after China criticized Australia, the situation changed completely.
All western governments support Australia, and all western media also support Australia.
I think this is too strange. The Australian government was still apologizing the day before, but the attitude was completely reversed the next day.
What is the psychological state of this transition? How to explain this shift?

************

My focus is how to explain this shift.
The popular opinion on the Chinese Internet is that white arrogance, white supremacy, double standards.
I want to know what people in other countries think? Do you agree with this explanation
In non-linear warfare, particularly counter insurgency it’s hard to keep troops from acting out when they are frustrated. It’s a sign of a breakdown in discipline. Many armies look the other way if they think it won’t undermine the overall mission.

while not an issue during the immediate war, stories of atrocities can undermine future cooperation by local populations or governments with that country.

It’s not always racism primarily, but it’s always some form of dehumanization of the enemy.

Watch the movie “Saving Private Ryan”. When the US troops take the machine gun nests and the Germans are surrendering, some of the US troops still kill them.

Watch from 3:03-3:30
In full metal jacket


Absolute power corrupts absolutely
I’ll let an Indian politician put it most clearly

Its about how soldiers are taught to wage war. There is a famous massacre of Italians and Germans during the invasion of Sicily. You can see how easily it can happen, depending on the orders from the top. Sun Tzu says when the orders are not clear it is the fault of the commander. In the case of Sicily it was Patton’s fault.

 
Last edited:

Cherub786

BANNED
Jul 28, 2020
748
-2
545
Country
Canada
Location
Canada
The Anglos haven't done even 1% of the genocides and autogenocides which East Asians, especially Chinese, have perpetrated in recent modern history.
 

Itachi

BANNED
Aug 27, 2013
3,300
0
3,445
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
Ah I agree. Might is right. We apply that to Xinjiang too. Religious extremists are being purged and that's just how it is. We are stronger thus we deserve the land more, in addition to being the first ones there. Sucks to be an Uighur Wahhabi fundamentalist.

We respect their religion. They want to meet god? PLA sets up the meeting.
You seem to be a deluded one.....along with wrong historical facts. :lol:

I would like to make a comparison between the amount of Han Chinese who died in 2020 vs all the Uyghurs who died fighting Han Chinese since 1900's...

Guess which number will be higher my little foolish friend? :D
 
Last edited:

Beast

BANNED
Feb 5, 2011
23,452
-38
55,055
Country
China
Location
China
You seem to a deluded one.....along with wrong historical facts. :lol:

I would like to make a comparison between the amount of Han Chinese who died in 2020 vs all the Uyghurs who died fighting Han Chinese since 1900's...

Guess which number will be higher my little foolish friend? :D
LOL.. As if u really have those accurate data. You pull it out from your rear, is it? :lol:
 
Last edited:

FairAndUnbiased

SENIOR MEMBER
Nov 25, 2011
7,692
0
11,542
Country
China
Location
United States
You seem to a deluded one.....along with wrong historical facts. :lol:

I would like to make a comparison between the amount of Han Chinese who died in 2020 vs all the Uyghurs who died fighting Han Chinese since 1900's...

Guess which number will be higher my little foolish friend? :D
lol make your list. Doesn't change the fact that Xinjiang is under Han control.
 

That Guy

PDF THINK TANK: ANALYST
Mar 29, 2013
11,511
39
14,429
Country
Pakistan
Location
Canada
You are just a slave to the Western media. If the Western media can correctly report on China, I think this is acceptable.
For example, Western media said that there was a massacre at Tiananmen Square. Can you provide evidence? photo? video? A telegram from the US Embassy to the United States that day indicated that there was no massacre that day. Spanish television footage also showed that there was no killing.
The West accuses China of imprisoning 1 million Uighurs. Is there any evidence? photo? image?
The problem with the Western media is that they always make accusations without evidence, and fools like you always believe in such accusations without evidence.
I ask you to present your evidence to prove the facts you believe.

This is why you defend yourself.
Whenever you receive criticism, your favorite thing to do is to silence others. :omghaha: :omghaha: :omghaha:
I'm gonna let the mods deal with you, considering you're just trolling now.
 

Itachi

BANNED
Aug 27, 2013
3,300
0
3,445
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
LOL.. As if u really have those accurate data. You put it our from your rear, is it? :lol:
You're right, CCP has hidden the actual data under its rear...

But we all know who'll have higher death count. :lol:

lol make your list. Doesn't change the fact that Xinjiang is under Han control.
Boundaries change all the time. You guys have a history of destabilization. I won't say more since we all know China can't do much other than put Uyghurs in "reeducation camps".

Open warfare will only lead to China becoming another Afghanistan. CCP knows that, I know that, you clearly live in another reality so you don't.
 

That Guy

PDF THINK TANK: ANALYST
Mar 29, 2013
11,511
39
14,429
Country
Pakistan
Location
Canada
Bro, why are you handing our Negative ratings like candy?

He has a legitimate question. Does it matter if he is Chinese?

It has no bearing on what he is asking, and actually it should be loudly asked of not just AUS, but US, Canada, NZ.

Natives were massacred and their land stolen from them, their children stolen from them and whitewashed.

@hualushui check out this book about American history from Native eyes. "Bury my Heart at Wounded Knee" by Dee Brown.
Because all he did was ignore my comment, and strawman me.

It's one thing to ask questions, it's something completely different to lie about another user's stance.

I highly suggest you go back and read my comments, as well as his replies to me.
Oh brother , language please.

I don't want to engage in China/Australia debate.
Other things mentioned are a facts.
Not only current, but last 500/600 history is proof of it.
Once again, I need evidence from OP's claim that the US and the EU defended Australia's war crimes.

Why is this so hard for everyone in this thread to do? All that's been done is needlessly attack me. If they had a valid argument to make, then they'd have presented evidence of US/EU defending Australian war crimes by now.
 

FairAndUnbiased

SENIOR MEMBER
Nov 25, 2011
7,692
0
11,542
Country
China
Location
United States
You're right, CCP has hidden the actual data under its rear...

But we all know who'll have higher death count. :lol:



Boundaries change all the time. You guys have a history of destabilization. I won't say more since we all know China can't do much other than put Uyghurs in "reeducation camps".

Open warfare will only lead to China becoming another Afghanistan. CCP knows that, I know that, you clearly live in another reality so you don't.
lol what? If Uighurs are in reeducation camps they're not getting out without permission. Once in the camps - if they exist - they are under full control of the military and police.

If you wait for China to destabilize, you'll be waiting 300+ years.
 

Cherub786

BANNED
Jul 28, 2020
748
-2
545
Country
Canada
Location
Canada
Ah I agree. Might is right. We apply that to Xinjiang too. Religious extremists are being purged and that's just how it is. We are stronger thus we deserve the land more, in addition to being the first ones there. Sucks to be an Uighur Wahhabi fundamentalist.

We respect their religion. They want to meet god? PLA sets up the meeting.
Let all Pakistani Muslims on PDF read this.
This is what the Chinese really think of you and your Religion
 

Beast

BANNED
Feb 5, 2011
23,452
-38
55,055
Country
China
Location
China
Let all Pakistani Muslims on PDF read this.
This is what the Chinese really think of you and your Religion
LOL.. Someone compare extreme religion militants = moderate peaceful muslim.

May I know what is problem with getting rid of ISIS and religion extremist? Maybe u r one of them?
You're right, CCP has hidden the actual data under its rear...

But we all know who'll have higher death count. :lol:
Of cos CPC has accurate data becos Xinjiang is part of China and they govern that area. U? only from your rear with make up numbers. :lol:
 

That Guy

PDF THINK TANK: ANALYST
Mar 29, 2013
11,511
39
14,429
Country
Pakistan
Location
Canada
Let all Pakistani Muslims on PDF read this.
This is what the Chinese really think of you and your Religion
Don't know why people are surprised. China is literally an atheist country, that strictly encourages, if not outright enforces atheism in all levels of society and government.
 

Itachi

BANNED
Aug 27, 2013
3,300
0
3,445
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
lol what? If Uighurs are in reeducation camps they're not getting out without permission. Once in the camps - if they exist - they are under full control of the military and police.

If you wait for China to destabilize, you'll be waiting 300+ years.
I don't need to wait that long. You're govt. is helping the cause already.

Of cos CPC has accurate data becos Xinjiang is part of China and they govern that area. U? only from your rear with make up numbers. :lol:
I was referring to how China has given no actual Covid-19 data regarding the actual death rate. Clearly you need to go back to school for English. Looks like you failed in English and came to PDF to show us your patriotism. :D

Run along wumao.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)


Top Bottom