What's new

Approach to Balochistan conflict

Approach to Balochistan conflict

  • More force

  • Peace initiative and concession


Results are only viewable after voting.

SuperStar20

FULL MEMBER
Jun 6, 2020
1,579
-6
747
Country
India
Location
India
What is the main reason for Balochistan conflict? If they want independence, there must be a reason. If discrimination in jobs, politics, freedom of expression, then talks and concession will work. They want independency no matter what then it can't be solved.

For example: Punjab problem is solved. After eliminating the militants
Kashmir- they just want to separate. Talks, concession did not work. that is why India following some of chinese templates in Xinjiang.
 

That Guy

PDF THINK TANK: ANALYST
Mar 29, 2013
12,476
40
16,502
Country
Canada
Location
Canada
A two-pronged approach is what's needed. Peace with groups that have legitimate concerns, and are willing to sit at the table. Force with groups that are India bought, or insist on armed conflict.
 
Last edited:

Azog

FULL MEMBER
Jun 26, 2015
244
0
231
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Blaming it on India is easy. Yes they might be funding the movement. We need to find reasons why these group are able to recruit so many people.

Establishment needs to stop interfering in Balochistan, stop creating fake party like BAP to control Balochistan from Rawalpindi. It creates a sense of deprivation. True Baloch leaders willing to accept Pakistan constitution needed to voted by Baloch people rather being selected.
 

khansaheeb

ELITE MEMBER
Dec 14, 2008
12,929
-7
14,920
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Kingdom
There is no conflict in Baluchistan. There is a WAR imposed by Indian terrorists, and as usual the Cowardly, dastardly Establishment of Pakistan and its Military is bending over and getting hammered daily. I am not surprised since this is the same country which keeps shamelessly quiet while its Kashmir brothers are getting butchered daily !
Pakistan is losing the information campaign and is unable to dampen polarisation between Baluchi rogues and Pro Pakistan Baluchs, due to Indian interference and financing of terror groups. We need to get the Taliban more involved in securing the border for that is where most of the arms and money is coming from and disrupt internal Pakistan networks who are supporting and fueling this. We must maintain communication lines with the rogues and settle genuine grievances. Crushing dissent is not the answer as the Indians have found in Kashmir and the British in Northern Ireland but political solutions acceptable to all sides. Only Baluchis can reign in other Baluchis and we don't want to alienate friendly Baluchis by hostile actions of PA.
 

Hakikat ve Hikmet

ELITE MEMBER
Nov 14, 2015
14,369
17
38,206
Country
United States
Location
United States
Traitors aren't tried, they are terminated - a Turkic saying

Please be my guest to try to be a traitor or terrorist in my hometown! All the officers in my local Sherrif's office would simulataneously fire the entire storage of bullets at the point blank rage targeting the upper body of that scum within a blink of an eye....
 

AZADPAKISTAN2009

ELITE MEMBER
Sep 8, 2009
34,581
66
37,306
Country
Pakistan
Location
China
Population of Balochistan Province

12,000,000

This is population of a small city in Western World


For people are peace minded
Solution
  • Free Education
  • Free Health Card
  • Jobs Program
    • Skills Jobs Training 25% reserved Jobs
      • Construction
      • Road Building
      • Housing
      • Plumbing
      • Roofing
      • Driving Transportation Job
    • Office Job Intern Ship with those with Education
  • Loan Program to open Restaurants on the Highway
    • Hire local Baluch workers in kitchen
  • Loan Program to Purchase Transport Trucks
Development of Pakistan Fishing Company
  • Hire local fishing workers Train them

Those in Remote Area
  • Support for Farming
    • Dates Farming
    • Olive Oil Farming

  • Protection from Pakistan Army
  • Protection from Border Force
  • UAV Protection from Air for Remote Highways and Roads
 
Last edited:

GumNaam

ELITE MEMBER
Sep 23, 2016
12,410
-13
17,244
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
I'm not gonna vote cuz the question itself is factually incorrect. there is no such thing as "balochistan conflict". reminants of a few thugs and goons for hire armed by indians does not qualify as a "conflict" by any stretch of the imagination.
 

waz

SENIOR MODERATOR
Sep 15, 2006
19,485
71
52,799
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Kingdom
Both needed but force is now the order of the day. The BLA/BLF and other commie filth are having a run.
 

khansaheeb

ELITE MEMBER
Dec 14, 2008
12,929
-7
14,920
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Kingdom
Population of Balochistan Province

12,000,000

This is population of a small city in Western World


For people are peace minded
Solution
  • Free Education
  • Free Health Card
  • Jobs Program
    • Skills Jobs Training 25% reserved Jobs
      • Construction
      • Road Building
      • Housing
      • Plumbing
      • Roofing
      • Driving Transportation Job
    • Office Job Intern Ship with those with Education
  • Loan Program to open Restaurants on the Highway
    • Hire local Baluch workers in kitchen
  • Loan Program to Purchase Transport Trucks
Development of Pakistan Fishing Company
  • Hire local fishing workers Train them

Those in Remote Area
  • Support for Farming
    • Dates Farming
    • Olive Oil Farming

  • Protection from Pakistan Army
  • Protection from Border Force
  • UAV Protection from Air for Remote Highways and Roads
If this was implemented then half of Pakistan would flock there.
 

FuturePAF

SENIOR MEMBER
Dec 17, 2014
7,015
20
8,136
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
If this was implemented then half of Pakistan would flock there.

That’s why a whole of country solution is needed. Each area of the country should have the same facilities per capita as any other. And the government will have to be able to explain to the more developed parts of the country why it is in their long term interest (and even short term interest if we can get mining ramped up) to cut their budgets (for a while) to get Baluchistan up to national standards.

Ways and means need to be identified to make it feasible that each area of the country grows, so people don’t well they need to migrate for better opportunities and they can have a bright future where they are currently located.

Also, so that current residents of the underdeveloped areas don’t feel the resources long promised to them will go to others before they themselves have caught up.

I would hope the government works with local elected and unelected leaders to identify where each region of the country would like to develop, and finding a way to reach these goals, especially with investors so these areas can get jobs for unemployed people. For example, in Baluchistan there is huge potential for solar power, and if power lines can be build to Karachi, it could power factories there with cheaper electricity, with money being paid to Baluchistan government as loyalties. Factories to build solar panels can be made in Baluchistan, factories for certain high value or mining based products can be built in Baluchistan and goods transported to Karachi or Gwadar.

If the government can lay out a real and realistic plan (with help from locals, government ministries, and industry leading consultants) and identify potential investors in the next 12 months, people can something to work forward to. This is why getting Reko-Diq up and running ASAP is so important. The Chinese could build a rail line directly from Gawadar north to the Iran-Quetta Line and get business going. This is also why CPEC phase 2 needs to get started ASAP.

On a social level, hopefully there are also local people that can try to convince miscreants to lay down their guns if they are found, before anyone loses their lives. If stopped, people might feel the government is really trying to turn things around. Through Rehabilitation of willing former militants and employment opportunities could end the pipeline of new miscreants (and help identify how foreign elements are trying to fund rebellions).
 
Last edited:

fisher1

BANNED
Jan 28, 2019
2,472
-22
2,386
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
If Pakistan can negotiate peace with TTP, why not Balochistan?

The solution to all these insurgencies is to progress the people and the state and remove poverty. Nobody sane would join these groups if they didn't have any grievances.

Balochistan is a very backward province with no funding, in fact, international aid agencies are collecting donations worldwide to help Balochi people. That is insane.

Instead of spending millions of dollars of my tax money to please Hindus/Sri Lankans/Chinese, why not give that money to Balochi people? You save one balochi family, that is generations of loyal patriotic Balochis.

But these require actual serious sincere people in power who want betterment of Pakistan which we don't have, never had since our founding fathers died.
 

Shehryar Ashraf

FULL MEMBER
Aug 18, 2021
201
1
289
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
the war is being prosecuted in the wrong direction.
hitting india where it hurts (mumbai) is the only way to end the balochistan conflict.
 

Mr.Green

FULL MEMBER
Dec 19, 2014
335
2
270
Country
Pakistan
Location
New Zealand
Traitors aren't tried, they are terminated - a Turkic saying

Please be my guest to try to be a traitor or terrorist in my hometown! All the officers in my local Sherrif's office would simulataneously fire the entire storage of bullets at the point blank rage targeting the upper body of that scum within a blink of an eye...
You look like a Gulen follower.
 

Bleek

SENIOR MEMBER
Dec 21, 2021
2,049
0
2,901
Country
United Kingdom
Location
United Kingdom
Population of Balochistan Province

12,000,000

This is population of a small city in Western World


For people are peace minded
Solution
  • Free Education
  • Free Health Card
  • Jobs Program
    • Skills Jobs Training 25% reserved Jobs
      • Construction
      • Road Building
      • Housing
      • Plumbing
      • Roofing
      • Driving Transportation Job
    • Office Job Intern Ship with those with Education
  • Loan Program to open Restaurants on the Highway
    • Hire local Baluch workers in kitchen
  • Loan Program to Purchase Transport Trucks
Development of Pakistan Fishing Company
  • Hire local fishing workers Train them

Those in Remote Area
  • Support for Farming
    • Dates Farming
    • Olive Oil Farming

  • Protection from Pakistan Army
  • Protection from Border Force
  • UAV Protection from Air for Remote Highways and Roads
Yep this is pretty much the only way, reasoning with current lunatics is off the table, you need to hunt them down, their minds are already plagued.

The future generation needs to be provided free adequate quality education. Instill patriotism and positive morals into them. With employment and opportunities they won't be easy targets for anti-state elements to fuel sectarian violence.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)


Top Bottom