What's new

ANALYSIS - Strategic, legal aspects of Turkey-Libya deal

dBSPL

SENIOR MEMBER
Mar 2, 2018
3,078
14
8,790
Country
Albania
Location
Turkey
Turkey 'checkmates' in Mediterranean Sea chess by taking legal and economic initiative in region with game changing Libya deal, which will change energy geopolitics in East Med.
by Mesut Hakki Casin |


Advancements in drilling technology over the past quarter-century bred maritime boundary disputes in the Eastern Mediterranean due to the rising demand for hydrocarbon resources. Contrary to territorial waters, establishing continental shelf limits and exclusive economic zones (EEZs) within overlapping maritime zones has been particularly problematic in the region.

Technically speaking, "maritime zone notifications" are unilateral declarations of contiguous zones, EEZ boundaries or coastal state territorial zones -- within maritime zones unconnected to other neighboring states. In contrast, "maritime boundary delimitations" correspond to the restrictions put in place via an agreement to determine relevant boundaries between states, in case of overlapping maritime zones or multiple claims to the area.

There are no such thorough agreements between the coastal states in the Eastern Mediterranean. Greek Cypriot administration of Southern Cyprus considers itself the sole authority on the island, while Greece, Libya, Egypt, Syria, Lebanon and Israel all declared EEZs in the Eastern Mediterranean region. But it is important to note that the EEZ agreements, between the EU and the U.S.-supported Greek-Cypriot duo and the coastal states, have no legitimacy due to the unlawful nature of the Eastern Mediterranean Gas Forum -- which disregards the rights of Turkey and the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus (TRNC), protected by international law.


The natural gas reserves in the region are estimated to be around 122 trillion cubic meters in total. In addition to the natural gas production in Israel and Egypt, the drilling activities in Cyprus significantly raised the status of the island for outsider states while simultaneously posing a question of regional strategic security. The Turkey-Libya deal herein resulted in the collapse of, the quite unlawful, political strategies.
Competition among great powers in region, risks of military conflict escalation

Rising energy demand in the EU raises Brussels’ political and economic interests in the region. The EU also supports the unjustified EEZ claims of Southern Cyprus and Greece. On the other hand, the political impotence caused by the Syrian civil war and the Arab Spring, as well as the newly formed blocs among countries with the current competition of global powers, have triggered an arms race and rise of tensions in the region rather than allowing for economic cooperation. Israel, Greece and Southern Cyprus are taking steps towards collaboration in economy, energy, defense and foreign policy issues. Saudi Arabia is officially a part of Southern Cyprus-Greece-Egypt bloc -- formed by the U.S. and Israel in the Eastern Mediterranean -- against Turkey. The Saudi regime, for the first time in history, sent a minister-level diplomat to Southern Cyprus, giving a signal of “unity against Turkey”.

Considering the possible contribution of the discovery of energy resources within these maritime zones on these nations’ economies and geopolitical positions, the option of “gunboat diplomacy” seems to remain in the forefront, rather than respecting international law in the Eastern Mediterranean. The U.S. and EU’s efforts in balancing Russia’s access to the Mediterranean Sea and the improvements in China's relations with the Mediterranean countries via the “Modern Silk Road Project”, put further pressure on the Cyprus Island. The Mediterranean Region is getting sucked into the center of an “undeclared war” as the U.S. and EU conduct more drills with the Gulf States and the Israel-Greece-Southern Cyprus trio to balance Russia, China and Iran. In other words, the rivalry to establish dominance in the region is turning into a Cold-War like conflict among the countries.

John McCarrick, deputy assistant secretary of the U.S. Department of State's Energy Resources Bureau, said in an interview on Nov. 29 that the U.S. is against the pipeline projects “TurkStream” and “Nord Stream II”, which are planning to transfer natural gas from Russia to Turkey and Germany -- through Turkey and the Baltic Sea. Turkey purchased the S-400 Russian missile system after Washington allowed Greece, but not Turkey, to get access to the Patriot missiles. While Greece happens to have Russian S-300 missiles in its inventories, it was surprising for many that Turkey, a NATO member, purchased Russian missile systems. Adopting a punitive approach towards Turkey, the U.S. agreed to lift a 32-year-long arms embargo on Southern Cyprus. Also, U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo said Turkey's activities of drilling for gas in the Eastern Mediterranean was “unacceptable”. Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis called on Washington to exercise authority to solve the problem. In the meantime, the EU supported the unlawful attempts of Southern Cyprus to sub-divide the region and conduct drillings via various companies and partners. Tensions rose as the Greek Cypriot leader Nicos Anastasiades reported Turkey, which started drillings in the Cyprus Island, to the UN, while the U.S. and EU supported the gas pipeline agreements among Southern Cyprus and some European countries and Israel against Turkey. Turkey, on the other hand, chose to go its way, conducting drillings in the region under the protection of its naval forces, after not getting much support from either the EU or U.S.



Legal background of Turkey-Libya deal

The Turkey-Libya Maritime Boundary Delimitation Agreement was signed by Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan and Chairman of the Presidential Council of Libya Fayiz es-Serrac on Nov. 27. The agreement is approved by the Grand National Assembly of Turkey and the UN will be informed of the agreement following the approval of Libya. Turkey, with the Libya deal, took a game-changing initiative that will historically have a major impact on the energy geopolitics of the Eastern Mediterranean. The hypothesis that Turkey could not have an agreement with the other states in the region is also proven wrong, and besides, doors to new agreements with Egypt, Lebanon and Israel are now open with the Libya deal. This also reaffirmed Turkey’s strong position in the game and proved that in legal and practical terms, it is not possible to ignore Turkey’s existence in the region.

The maritime boundary delimitation issue in the Eastern Mediterranean has unique factors that need consideration as the boundaries are set. The UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) proposes a fair and lawful distribution of maritime resources and delimitation of maritime zone boundaries. While the geographic conditions of the region lie at the core of the EEZ disputes within the Eastern Mediterranean, it is particularly the policies carried of the nations which have conflicts with the fundamental principles of the Convention, such as the principles of “justice”, “non-encroachment” and “equitable geographical distribution”. The international legal regime of EEZs were arranged in Articles 55-57 of Part V of the 1982 UNCLOS. According to Article 57 of the Convention: "The exclusive economic zone shall not extend beyond 200 nautical miles from the baselines from which the breadth of the territorial sea is measured.” Due to the distance between the countries being less than 400 nautical miles in the region, the EEZ boundaries can only be determined via agreements concluded between multiple states, and besides, islands can’t have complete control over EEZs, therefore they can’t declare sovereignty. The International Court of Justice indicated that the delimitations will be made according to common law, respecting the “justice” principles and taking into account all “related situations”, with an “agreement”.

Greece acknowledges as a single coastline, its territories within the area between the Crete Region and the Meyisti island. Turkey, on the other hand, argues that continental shelves and EEZ boundaries must be determined between the mainland states Libya, Egypt and Turkey, primarily. Southern Cyprus’ claim of mainland status in the Mediterranean Sea and the agreements built on that assumption are not valid according to international law. Also, according to the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, Southern Cyprus can’t ignore the equal rights of Northern Cyprus and unilaterally make decisions on behalf of the Turkish people living on the island. Turkey and TRNC made objections to the agreements, reporting that the agreement made between Cyprus and Egypt is violating the continental shelf boundaries of Turkey and that Southern Cyprus is seriously violating the TRNC’s equality rights and that these violations are against the principle of just distribution. This is because the coastal geography and structure play a very important role in the delimitation of maritime zones. It’s, more often than not, the deciding factor, and it’s built on two basic principles; “The Principal of the Domination of the Land over the Sea” and “the coastal state shall establish this domination via its coasts”. This fundamental principle has been highlighted in all related judicial decisions (Malta-Libya case, Aegean Sea Continental Shelf case, Guinea-Bissau case).



The strategic significance of the Turkey-Libya deal

The deal’s primary contribution was that it guaranteed the re-drawing of the EEZ and continental shelf zone boundaries within the Eastern Mediterranean, as it is the second maritime boundary delimitation agreement -- following the agreement concluded with the TRNC -- signed in the Eastern Mediterranean with a riparian state, while Greece’s agreements with Egypt and Southern Cyprus have lost their legitimacy for the most part.

As summarized above, according to the “non-encroachment” principle, it would be against the law to grant to Greece only the maritime zones that are near the shores of Turkey (whose coasts are the longest in magnitude in the Eastern Mediterranean). Turkey scored a historic victory with the Libya deal, penetrating through the so-called EEZ line, which was seriously violating the rights of the TRNC and the 533 nautical mile-long Anatolian coast in the Eastern Mediterranean, in the Western direction. The third critical achievement was the establishment of Libya as a Turkish maritime neighbor, and vice-versa, via the principle of the “creation of diagonal lines”, due to the tilted geographical position of Turkey on the world map. This situation will allow Turkey (and not Greece) to conclude similar agreements with Egypt and Israel in the future.

Greek Prime Minister Mitsotakis is hoping to gain the support of the White House in his US visit and strengthen his hand on the Egypt-Greece EEZ boundary delimitation agreement. The EU asserted that it will stand by the Greece-Cyprus duo regarding the current issue and invited Turkey to act in correspondence with the European Neighborhood Policy, and highlighted that the agreement text should be published. Southern Cyprus, on the other hand, announced that it’s preparing an appeal to the International Court of Justice. But according to Article 59 of the UNCLOS, "the conflict should be resolved based on equity and in the light of all the relevant circumstances, taking into account the respective importance of the interests involved to the parties as well as to the international community as a whole." in cases of conflicting interests among states. Secretary-General of NATO Jens Stoltenberg, on his way to the 2019 NATO summit in London, responded a question on Turkey’s drilling activities in the Eastern Mediterranean. “Both Greece and Turkey are valued allies and both contribute to our shared security. There are some disagreements and I welcome that there are bilateral contacts are trying to address these differences,” Stoltenberg said, adding that NATO is not a part of these bilateral talks. He also said that one of the reasons NATO has succeeded is that it does not participate “in all the difficult issues” of the region. This is an indication that the Greeks are spinning their wheels if anything.

In conclusion, Turkey is holding the key to a brand new chapter in the Mediterranean region, and we can expect that Turkey will continue the process peacefully and in line with the UNCLOS spirit, starting the dialogue which will enable the fair distribution of resources in the region among all states.

source link: https://www.aa.com.tr/en/africa/analysis-strategic-legal-aspects-of-turkey-libya-deal/1673079

 

MMM-E

SENIOR MEMBER
Jul 6, 2017
5,301
-2
5,662
Country
Turkey
Location
Germany
That is Turkey's claim. It is not recognized by international law or conventions
GAME OVER ! the UN nor Greece have the right to make a deal signed between Turkey and Libya invalid, and thus their efforts are pointless

The deal reached between Turkey and Libya officially went into force on Dec. 8, Turkey announced while submitting a memorandum of understanding to the UN

We dont care about bandit countries like France,Italy,Greece,Israel who are trying to steal oil-gas reserves from the Turks in the Eastern Mediterranean

Turkey has the longest shoreline in the Mediterranean
If Turkey had not taken these steps by considering the developments in the region in accordance with international law, the country would have faced the risk of losing its rights in the Eastern Mediterranean
 

nahtanbob

BANNED
Sep 24, 2018
7,231
-35
2,392
Country
United States
Location
United States
GAME OVER ! the UN nor Greece have the right to make a deal signed between Turkey and Libya invalid, and thus their efforts are pointless

The deal reached between Turkey and Libya officially went into force on Dec. 8, Turkey announced while submitting a memorandum of understanding to the UN
you cannot unilaterally declare your EEZ
 

MMM-E

SENIOR MEMBER
Jul 6, 2017
5,301
-2
5,662
Country
Turkey
Location
Germany
you cannot unilaterally declare your EEZ
EEZ border deal between Turkey and Libya shows Turkey determined to protect rights

President ERDOGAN said that Other international actors cannot conduct exploration activities in the areas marked in the memorandum

and Greek Cypriots, Egypt, Greece and Israel cannot establish a natural gas transmission line without Turkey’s consen

GAME OVER !
 

nahtanbob

BANNED
Sep 24, 2018
7,231
-35
2,392
Country
United States
Location
United States
EEZ border deal between Turkey and Libya shows Turkey determined to protect rights

President ERDOGAN said that Other international actors cannot conduct exploration activities in the areas marked in the memorandum

and Greek Cypriots, Egypt, Greece and Israel cannot establish a natural gas transmission line without Turkey’s consen

GAME OVER !
libya-turkey deal means squat
 

MMM-E

SENIOR MEMBER
Jul 6, 2017
5,301
-2
5,662
Country
Turkey
Location
Germany
libya-turkey deal means squat

Before the Turkish-Libyan maritime deal, Greece, Israel and the Greek Cypriots were trying to outmanoeuvre Turkey by designating their own EEZs, signing agreements among themselves


We dont care about bandit countries .... Turkish Armed Forces have enough power to protect Turkey's and Turkish Cypriots EEZ

Greek Cypriots, Egypt, Greece and Israel cannot establish a natural gas transmission line without Turkey’s consen
 

nahtanbob

BANNED
Sep 24, 2018
7,231
-35
2,392
Country
United States
Location
United States
Before the Turkish-Libyan maritime deal, Greece, Israel and the Greek Cypriots were trying to outmanoeuvre Turkey by designating their own EEZs, signing agreements among themselves


We dont care about bandit countries .... Turkish Armed Forces have enough power to protect Turkey's and Turkish Cypriots EEZ

Greek Cypriots, Egypt, Greece and Israel cannot establish a natural gas transmission line without Turkey’s consen
if you did not care about bandit countries you would not be signing the Libya deal with a faction
 

Rukarl

FULL MEMBER
May 13, 2015
1,731
-12
2,155
Country
Iran, Islamic Republic Of
Location
Iran, Islamic Republic Of
We dont care about bandit countries .... Turkish Armed Forces have enough power to protect Turkey's and Turkish Cypriots EEZ
Why doesnt the turkish armed forces lift the gaza blockade ?
 

MMM-E

SENIOR MEMBER
Jul 6, 2017
5,301
-2
5,662
Country
Turkey
Location
Germany
Why doesnt the turkish armed forces lift the gaza blockade ?
GAZA is not Turkish territory and Palestinians are not Turks

500 million Arabs should lift the gaza blockade


No more tolerance to bandit Countries and their lapdogs

Turkey blocks Israeli vessel conducting research off eastern Cyprus

an Israeli vessel conducting research activity on the Turkish continental shelf off the coast of Cyprus was blocked by the Turkish Navy two weeks ago, Israeli sources reported on Saturday


The unilaterally declared its Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) of the Greek Cypriot administration violates part of Turkey's shelf particularly in Blocks 1, 4, 5, 6 and 7

https://www.dailysabah.com/politics...vessel-conducting-research-off-eastern-cyprus
 
Last edited:

Turan09

FULL MEMBER
May 31, 2019
638
0
1,248
Country
Turkey
Location
Turkey
GAZA is not Turkish territory and Palestinians are not Turks

500 million Arabs should lift the gaza blockade
[/URL]
I couldn't agree you more... We are not gonna spend our valuable resources and Turkish lives for Palestine. It is not our fight.
 

MMM-E

SENIOR MEMBER
Jul 6, 2017
5,301
-2
5,662
Country
Turkey
Location
Germany
I can't agree you more... We are not gonna spend our valuable resources and Turkish lives for Palestine. It is not our fight.
I dont care about Palestinians and Arabs
but We Turks always will defend Jerusalem from bandit country Israel ( radical Zionist Israel has plans to take Jerusalem , Cyprus , parts of Syria , Iraq , Turkey , Iran , Egypt , Jordan , S.Arabia for greater Israel called the promised land was God's gift to his chosen people of Israel )


Its our fight ( 1,7 billion Islamic World ) and Jerusalem never will be belonged to Israel , not even in their dreams
 
Last edited:

Oublious

SENIOR MEMBER
Jun 23, 2012
6,025
-1
6,530
Country
Turkey
Location
Netherlands
you cannot unilaterally declare your EEZ

But your goverment tell us to respect cyprus and greec EEZ. And did give them advice to open a gasform with israel. And when we declar our EEZ is wrong?

Ther is one justice and that is showing POWER. Other wise you and your thugs with Egypt had stolen EEZ and nobody would talked about it:-).
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)


Top Bottom