What's new

America abandoned India in Afghanistan?

Zeeshank9.com

FULL MEMBER

New Recruit

Apr 17, 2019
20
1
39
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Gen. Tariq Khan, ex Head Pakistan's Central Command and Frontier Corps that defeated Pakistani Taliban (TTP) in a provocative interview with Dr. Moeed Pirzada (Editor GVS) explains how Washington has abandoned its ally India and its proxy Kabul regime in another shift of US politics. But he busts the myth of Afghan invincibility pointing out how both Sikhs under Maharaja Ranjit Singh and British had repeatedly defeated and humbled the rulers of Kabul. Highly informative discussion. Must watch for students of International Relations, Politics and aspirants of competitive exams like CSS, IAS and PAS.
 
Last edited:

aziqbal

PDF THINK TANK: ANALYST
Aug 26, 2010
3,482
9
5,520
Country
United Kingdom
Location
United Kingdom
India has had many consulates and embassies in Afghanistan

they were never stamping visas they were collecting intelligence

now with Taliban in power no more attacks will come to Pakistan

they are our people and we will inshallah start this new relationship based on trust and mutual understanding

india + Israel wanted the US to stay in Afghanistan

I see this a great victory for Pakistan

Gen. Tariq Khan is a great tactician
 

prothought

FULL MEMBER

New Recruit

May 22, 2021
71
0
101
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Taliban a CIA creation will work for CIA interest..
Yes, of course. That's why Afghan Taliban are kicking Indian *** in Afghanistan. Earlier CIA also abandoned these filthy Indians and signed a peace deal with Afghan Taliban. So, in that respect, both CIA and Afghan Taliban have shared interests and want to cooperate in killing Indians. CIA brought the enemy (i.e. Indians) tied and exposed in front of Afghan Taliban who are now doing their part.
 

Ali_Baba

SENIOR MEMBER
May 27, 2018
2,559
-1
3,669
Country
United Kingdom
Location
United Kingdom
India has had many consulates and embassies in Afghanistan

they were never stamping visas they were collecting intelligence

now with Taliban in power no more attacks will come to Pakistan
Agree - the recent uptick in violence in Pakistan is India basically using up her resources to perform these terrorist attacks in Pakistan while it has its terrorist infrastructure available in Afghanistan. That infrastructure will now dimish as it no longer has the patronage of the USA to create and support this terrorist infrastructure in Afghanistan.

In the same way that an Army "fires" off ammunition that will be "date expire" before it comes date expired to get some value from that ammunition(ie training of soldiers etc), India is doing the same with its terrorists ..

The violence will come down in time very soon.
 

Meengla

SENIOR MEMBER
Aug 1, 2009
4,766
17
7,118
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
Looking at the relatively lukewarm responses to the Taliban victories, I tend to believe Americans have resigned themselves to a major Taliban role in Afghanistan. Indians were always expendable. Until the Indian lobby in America becomes strong like Israel's lobby, India's main utility to Washington was that India is a big market and a good 'partner' to contain China. But the 'Law of Diminishing Returns' have their own ways.

BUT... it is still too early to saw what will Washington do after a few weeks/months as it re-assess developments in Afghanistan. So Tick Tock...

I just hope that a political solution is found where the Talibans are given control of much of the southern portions of Afghanistan to provide a buffer for Pakistan against the Indian machinations while the northern part of Afghanistan be retained with those who don't want to be ruled by the Talibans. A bifurcation of the country. And why not? Biden himself just said that 'Afghanistan has never been a united country'
 

Imran Khan

PDF VETERAN
Oct 18, 2007
59,750
2
118,332
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Looking at the relatively lukewarm responses to the Taliban victories, I tend to believe Americans have resigned themselves to a major Taliban role in Afghanistan. Indians were always expendable. Until the Indian lobby in America becomes strong like Israel's lobby, India's main utility to Washington was that India is a big market and a good 'partner' to contain China. But the 'Law of Diminishing Returns' have their own ways.

BUT... it is still too early to saw what will Washington do after a few weeks/months as it re-assess developments in Afghanistan. So Tick Tock...

I just hope that a political solution is found where the Talibans are given control of much of the southern portions of Afghanistan to provide a buffer for Pakistan against the Indian machinations while the northern part of Afghanistan be retained with those who don't want to be ruled by the Talibans. A bifurcation of the country. And why not? Biden himself just said that 'Afghanistan has never been a united country'
i think US will not respect any treaty and somehow will manage to use drones over afghanistan for long time . after they windrow they will start drone attacks both for revenge and for keeping taliban in control .
 

mudas777

FULL MEMBER
Oct 24, 2016
1,340
0
2,426
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Kingdom
Gen. Tariq Khan, ex Head Pakistan's Central Command and Frontier Corps that defeated Pakistani Taliban (TTP) in a provocative interview with Dr. Moeed Pirzada (Editor GVS) explains how Washington has abandoned its ally India and its proxy Kabul regime in another shift of US politics. But he busts the myth of Afghan invincibility pointing out how both Sikhs under Maharaja Ranjit Singh and British had repeatedly defeated and humbled the rulers of Kabul. Highly informative discussion. Must watch for students of International Relations, Politics and aspirants of competitive exams like CSS, IAS and PAS.

US never married India so when ever US needs India for her satisfaction will send India the flowers and the card written strategic allies. Once using India, US will go about their own business.
 

Xestan

SENIOR MEMBER
Sep 25, 2009
2,084
3
2,977
Edit: Merged thread, so that's why you'll see this weird explanation lol

Here's an interesting conversation, it follows up on the article written by the General quite recently.

People who like to read history, especially Afghanistan and Pashtoons would find some interesting facts in the interview. Furthermore, the General talks about Taliban takeover, its effect on Pakistan, our own fight against extremism, CPEC, Americans and also Americans abandoning Indians in Afghanistan.

 
Last edited:

huckyang

BANNED
Apr 27, 2008
417
-4
483
Edit: Merged thread, so that's why you'll see this weird explanation lol

Here's an interesting conversation, it follows up on the article written by the General quite recently.

People who like to read history, especially Afghanistan and Pashtoons would find some interesting facts in the interview. Furthermore, the General talks about Taliban takeover, its effect on Pakistan, our own fight against extremism, CPEC, Americans and also Americans abandoning Indians in Afghanistan.

US abandoned everyone when they are not serving their selfish interest anymore. No surprise. For US no one is friend, the only time they are friends means they are up to something Menace.
 

cloud4000

SENIOR MEMBER
Oct 11, 2015
4,519
-5
4,383
Country
India
Location
United States
India knew the US was leaving Afghanistan since Trump was POTUS, so it should not come as a surprise. India even refused to send troops at Trump’s request.

Besides why should US risk its interests to serve India‘s interests in Afghanistan?
 

gulli

BANNED
Jul 24, 2017
1,320
-8
748
Country
India
Location
India
India knew the US was leaving Afghanistan since Trump was POTUS, so it should not come as a surprise. India even refused to send troops at Trump’s request.

Besides why should US risk its interests to serve India‘s interests in Afghanistan?
Things to realize, India is far beyond Taliban.. Pakistan is in nearby vicinity..
 

HAIDER

ELITE MEMBER
May 21, 2006
24,750
13
24,855
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
Taliban a CIA creation will work for CIA interest..
India made mistake, they thought Trump remains in power and they will convince him to provide security to Indians in Afghanistan. Indian should have pulled before US pulled for the safety of their workforce. Plus, if you remember, Trump taunt Modi ... I need your forces, I don't need your library in Kabul

 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 2, Members: 0, Guests: 2)


Top Bottom