What's new

Afghan refugees protesting for citizenship in India

jupiter2007

SENIOR MEMBER
Feb 19, 2007
4,230
-1
2,967
They usually do its only those with literally no documents and no proof of when they entered the country who cant get citizenship. Still people in that situation could usually bribe their way through the process, I dont think its much different today.
2nd generation of Afghans and 3rd generations of Bengalis living in Pakistan should be granted Citizenship. Pakistani government should recognize this problem and find a clear solution for it. There needs to be a methodical, gradual, strict and step wise registration and integration process.

IMHO, government should start the process by allowing online applications for the citizenship process.
  • Online application, submit birth certification for applicant (and parents), college, university degree, Higher Secondary School Certificate (HSSC) or any paper work from schools for background check process, assets/property paper work.
  • Application review process and background check, criminal checks.
  • Interview process (pass and fail), specially trained people need to conduct the interviews.
  • Issue Computerized National Identity Card (CNIC) and 5 years permanent residence card (PRC) and should be given domicile for smaller cities.
  • During the 5 years with PRC, if they are not involve in any criminal activity and they are part of TAXNET, they can apply for citizenship.
  • Citizenship oath ceremony


1611594848169.png
 
Last edited:

FuturePAF

SENIOR MEMBER
Dec 17, 2014
3,588
18
4,338
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
What she and her fellows want basically is for India to officially extradite them so they can look for 1st world countries for asylum, they are treating India as a transit state
Interesting analysis. It could work, if they claim the first country they tried has rejected them.
 

KurtisBrian

FULL MEMBER
Aug 24, 2020
1,018
-5
289
Country
Canada
Location
Canada
What the heck are they doing in India? They are not the responsibility of Indians. They are not Hindus nor Indians. They didn't build anything in India. Every beggar wants something for nothing.
 

FuturePAF

SENIOR MEMBER
Dec 17, 2014
3,588
18
4,338
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
2nd generation of Afghans and 3rd generations of Bengalis living in Pakistan should be granted Citizenship. Pakistani government should recognize this problem and find a clear solution for it. There needs to be a methodical, gradual, strict and step wise registration and integration process.

IMHO, government should start the process by allowing online applications for the citizenship process.
  • Online application, submit birth certification for applicant (and parents), college, university degree, Higher Secondary School Certificate (HSSC) or any paper work from schools for background check process, assets/property paper work.
  • Application review process and background check, criminal checks.
  • Interview process (pass and fail), specially trained people need to conduct the interviews.
  • Issue Computerized National Identity Card (CNIC) and 5 years permanent residence card (PRC) and should be given domicile for smaller cities.
  • During the 5 years with PRC, if they are not involve in any criminal activity and they are part of TAXNET, they can apply for citizenship.


View attachment 710424
The best option for the government is to hope peace comes to Afghanistan so that refugees can go back, and build a life there.

Considering many are born in Pakistan and it is the only country they know, permanent residence would be the most Pakistani citizens would probably be ok with allowing. But citizenship would only work if both countries merged, which doesn’t seem to be under consideration by anyone.

Once peace is achieved, free movement of peoples should be I only allowed to support economic development of both countries.

This is a tough issue, considering there are people 41 and younger (since the Soviet invasion) that know no other country but Pakistan as their home.
 

peagle

FULL MEMBER
Dec 29, 2019
1,094
3
2,675
Country
United Kingdom
Location
United Kingdom
2nd generation of Afghans and 3rd generations of Bengalis living in Pakistan should be granted Citizenship. Pakistani government should recognize this problem and find a clear solution for it. There needs to be a methodical, gradual, strict and step wise registration and integration process.

IMHO, government should start the process by allowing online applications for the citizenship process.
  • Online application, submit birth certification for applicant (and parents), college, university degree, Higher Secondary School Certificate (HSSC) or any paper work from schools for background check process, assets/property paper work.
  • Application review process and background check, criminal checks.
  • Interview process (pass and fail), specially trained people need to conduct the interviews.
  • Issue Computerized National Identity Card (CNIC) and 5 years permanent residence card (PRC) and should be given domicile for smaller cities.
  • During the 5 years with PRC, if they are not involve in any criminal activity and they are part of TAXNET, they can apply for citizenship.
  • Citizenship oath ceremony


View attachment 710424
Regarding the Bengalis, and there are also lot of Rohingya in Pakistan, regarding those two groups, I agree, we should give them citizenship as per your suggestion.

But, not at any price for the Afghans, I used to have lots of love for this nation, but their constant vile hate towards Pakistan, even after 40+ years of looking after them, has changed my mind. Now, I actually hate them.

About a year ago, Imran Khan suggested we should open the possibility of a nationality route for the Afghans, there was a massive backlash, at the time I thought why not, they are our brothers after-all. Anyway, a guy I know, friend of a friend, we were discussing it, and I made a similar suggestion as yours, he nearly bite my head off, he said they will destroy our country, eat us from the inside.

About him, he is an accountant raised in Pakistan and I think has only been in the UK around maybe 8 years or so, and he's a Pathan from KPK, very decent guy, so I was surprised at his reaction. That day, any doubt I had in my mind was gone forever.

So, for Afghans give them nationality, if you have a desire to destroy your own country.
 

-blitzkrieg-

SENIOR MEMBER
Mar 1, 2015
3,359
2
4,023
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Afghan refugees protesting for citizenship in India.
Indian Muslims may start migrating to Pakistan once she overtakes India economically.
'Who will marry me here, myself afghan girl"

What sort of title is that on thumbnail of the video by the pervi indian .
Is that an invitation to indian public to apply for bob and vagene ?
 

-blitzkrieg-

SENIOR MEMBER
Mar 1, 2015
3,359
2
4,023
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Is that all your tiny brain can comprehend? Maybe it's not your fault, maybe you ran into some bachabaz molvi during your madarasa days which affected your mental development.
i know you are burning from inside that i took note of that minor detail unlike others.
stay calm,relax dont make your blood pressure shoot.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)


Top Bottom