[/QUOTE]the people welcomed him with song. There are certain occasions when it is allowed.[/QUOTE]
It's not obligatory. I feel it is not right to make songs about prophet (SAW). Showing signs of love. Similar to almighty. Now, that second thing I find is praying to graves and believing healing techniques. You can read it and understand. http://www.sullivan-county.com/wcva/sufism.htm
ch rehmat ali had got nothing to do with PAKISTAN. it was not his idea. the idea of partition he gave was labelled as "Childish" by Mr Jinnah. the guy in the thread is either false flag or a racist bastard... who doesnot know shiitt about CREATION OF PAKISTAN and great human ideals behind its creation.
and by the way from 1857 to 1941 there were 182 different scholars, intellectuals, leaders who suggested the idea of partition of india as the solution, in their writings, many even made detail maps of it. I made the list myself of these authors, in my college days.
I can answer him but it would be like giving him importance he is looking for.