Seiko Dear,
I replied to you very clearly. A vast Indian muslims majority has a clear cut opinion about Vande Matram as being ANTI-ISLAMIC in its present form. The stanza of the song clearly and un-ambigousely refer to Hindu Godess Durga. It is acknowldged by all relevent muslim scholar and religious bodies in India.
The PROJECTED muslims by media, to which you are reffering to, are paid-ups at best ! Your claim would have some substance had you reffered to some authentic and credible religious muslim body or forum substantiating your claim. Nothing of that sort!
Ignorance is a bliss, some time at least, as it look from your knowldge or claim, that some muslims you know, sing Vande Matram. Explain them the true meaning and Fatwas against it from muslim religous scholars and bodies and then ask thier reaction! You may get few surprises!
As you say yourself SC has given a clear judgement about singing or not singing it. Fatwas are needed for the people who want to know what Islamic Sharia has to say in certain issue. Fatwa against or in response to validity of Vande Matram are issued keeping this point in view. Interpretation of Fatwas is a individual issue among muslims. But it seems that Fatwas, that are essentially meant for muslims specifically, have a considerable interest among no-muslims as well!
