What's new

Why did you accept US award without govt clearance? Govt asks Army chief

Indo-guy

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Aug 14, 2013
Messages
4,820
Reaction score
2
Country
India
Location
Singapore
Why did you accept US award without govt clearance? Govt asks Army chief - The Times of India?



NEW DELHI: The acceptance of a US military award by Army chief Gen Bikram Singh has not gone down well with the defence ministry which has sent a poser to him asking why he received it without government clearance.

The Army chief was conferred with the 'Legion of Merit', the sixth highest American military honour, during his visit to the US from December 2 to 5.

The defence ministry has claimed that it came to know about it only through media reports after the conferment as it was not part of Gen Singh's itinerary provided prior to the visit, sources said.

Unhappy over it, the defence ministry has sought to know from the Army chief why he accepted the award without clearance from the government, the sources said.

The defence ministry has argued that services chiefs have to have clearance from the government to receive foreign honours.

When contacted for a reaction, Army headquarters here said they were not aware of the issue.

By receiving the honour, Gen Bikram Singh joined the ranks of legendary figures of the Indian Army including Field Marshal KM Kariappa.

The award is given to services chiefs and officers for exceptionally meritorious conduct in the performance of outstanding services and achievements.

Gen Singh is the fifth Indian armed forces officer to have received the award after Field Marshal Kariappa and first Indian Chief of Army Staff Gen Rajendra Singhji.

The 'Legion of Merit' decoration is issued both to United States military personnel and to military and political figures of foreign governments.

The Army chief visited the US at a time when the force is planning to procure M-777 ultra light howitzers and Javelin anti-tank missiles from there and the issues are expected to have come up for discussion there.
 
I Think the Army Chief should have followed the rules.
 
By receiving the honour, Gen Bikram Singh joined the ranks of legendary figures of the Indian Army including Field Marshal KM Kariappa.

Legion of Merit is given to any Service Chief visiting the US in recognition of their work to increase cooperation, interoperability between the respective forces. Its a very common thing.
 
Legion of Merit is given to any Service Chief visiting the US in recognition of their work to increase cooperation, interoperability between the respective forces. Its a very common thing.

this is TOI...they have to sensationalize everything ..they know 90% of the population have got no clue about this
 
Just goes to show Indian civil leadership is overkeen to exert it's superiority over the armed forces & keep them in check!
 
I think its NOT award but a TITLE and if I am not wrong Article 18 of Indian constitution forbids Indian National from accepting any TITLE from other States without prior permission from GOI.

If anybody remember same thing was happened about "Nishan-e-Pakistan" ;)
 
Just goes to show Indian civil leadership is overkeen to exert it's superiority over the armed forces & keep them in check!

How do yo know that the award was not given to the Army chief for sanctioning the purchase of M777 howitzer guns ?

How do you know for sure its not a quid pro quo ?

In fact it raises several uncomfortable questions about what exactly did the General offer for this award ? Did he leak any secrets ? What did he offer in exchange ? Bikram singh is already a tainted army officer due to his involvement and cover up of the Congo sex scandal.

Considering the fact that US is not a friendly nation and has demonstrated anti India activity by encouraging defection from Sr. RAW officer Rabinder Singh and providing him refuge, the Army chief certainly should not have accepted this without notifying the Govt. of India.

Legion of Merit is given to any Service Chief visiting the US in recognition of their work to increase cooperation, interoperability between the respective forces. Its a very common thing.

Maybe its as common as a street hooker, that does not mean the Army chief can flout service rules.
 
I Think the Army Chief should have followed the rules.

should he have asked if you shake hands too, or who puts a garland around his neck? It is a mundane award..

How do yo know that the award was not given to the Army chief for sanctioning the purchase of M777 howitzer guns ?

How do you know for sure its not a quid pro quo ?

In fact it raises several uncomfortable questions about what exactly did the General offer for this award ? Did he leak any secrets ? What did he offer in exchange ? Bikram singh is already a tainted army officer due to his involvement and cover up of the Congo sex scandal.

Considering the fact that US is not a friendly nation and has demonstrated anti India activity by encouraging defection from Sr. RAW officer Rabinder Singh and providing him refuge, the Army chief certainly should not have accepted this without notifying the Govt. of India.



Maybe its as common as a street hooker, that does not mean the Army chief can flout service rules.


How do you know he was not going to be an american spy?

how do you know he did not get the award because he promised to come slap some sense into you afterwards?

how do How do ? :lol:

You think a piece of metal is the award someone would seek, if they were looking for one, let alone as a " reward" for M777 deal?
 
How do you know he was not going to be an american spy?
how do you know he did not get the award because he promised to come slap some sense into you afterwards?
how do How do ? :lol:
You think a piece of metal is the award someone would seek, if they were looking for one, let alone as a " reward" for M777 deal?

So clearly you are an American citizen or is it Green Card holder ? LOL.

There are no Free Lunches. Even 'awards' have strings attached to them. That is the whole point of giving 'awards' :lol:

Too bad the Indian govt. looks down on your crappy award.
 
Just goes to show Indian civil leadership is overkeen to exert it's superiority over the armed forces & keep them in check!
Why are these yahoos in the MoD so pissed off?

And needless to say, the 'approval' for it would be signed by a lowly deputy secretary or some such idiot representing the GoI.
 
Why are these yahoos in the MoD so pissed off?

And needless to say, the 'approval' for it would be signed by a lowly deputy secretary or some such idiot representing the GoI.

Because the Deputy Consul General of the Indian consulate was just arrested, handcuffed and humiliated by the US Govt. ?
 
So clearly you are an American citizen or is it Green Card holder ? LOL.

There are no Free Lunches. Even 'awards' have strings attached to them. That is the whole point of giving 'awards' :lol:

Too bad the Indian govt. looks down on your crappy award.

I am someone who is above your intellect that is for sure. You just accused your General, a man of repute, a man who dedicated his life to protecting his country while you played guli danda and chased girls, as being a sellout and traitor- based on no proof.

You are the kind of citizen that demeans the country they belong to. Worse yet you showed that you think indians are easily bought off by a medal.

Now how dumb do you have to be to peddle that meme:lol:
 

Back
Top Bottom