What's new

Tajikistan: No Hajj, No Hijab, and Shave Your Beard

Is secularism inherently dogmatic and intolerant ?


  • Total voters
    47

Luffy 500

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jan 2, 2012
Messages
5,562
Reaction score
2
Tajikistan: No Hajj, No Hijab, and Shave Your Beard
In a Muslim-majority country, state control of religious expression tightens.

thediplomat_2015-04-16_15-42-51-386x257.jpg


Technically, freedom of religion is enshrined in the constitution of Tajikistan. But in reality, religious practice–at least for members of the country’s Muslim majority–is tightly controlled by the state. In recent months, Tajikistan has further steadied its grip on the practice of Islam with the president commenting on proper attire, reports of forced beard-shavings, and new regulations on who can travel to Mecca on hajj.

Until last month’s parliamentary elections, Tajikistan was the only Central Asian state in which political Islam had representation. The Islamic Renaissance Party of Tajikistan (IRPT) is widely touted as the only legally registered religious party in the region. While true, in the March election (unsurprisingly flawed) the IRPT lost, and for the first time since its legalization following the civil war will be out of government entirely. To add insult to injury the country’s official religious bodies have called for the IRPT to be banned, and some have suggested it should be labeled a terrorist organization.

The tightening grip of the state on Islam extends beyond politics. The State Committee on Religious Affairs (CRA) is responsible for overseeing and implementing laws relating to religion–including registration of religious groups, regulation of imports of religious materials, and oversight of mosques and churches. The Council of Ulema guides the Tajik Muslim community and while nominally independent, presents a state-approved version of Islam.

There are laws on the books banning female students from wearing hijabs, prohibiting those under the age of 18 from from participating in public religious activities, except funerals, which are regulated anyway. According to the U.S. Department of State’s 2013 International Religious Freedom Report:

The law regulates private celebrations and funeral services, including weddings and Mavludi Payghambar (the Prophet Muhammad’s birthday). The law limits the number of guests, eliminates engagement parties, and controls ceremonial gift presentations and other rituals. The religion law reiterates these principles, mandating that “mass worship, religious traditions, and ceremonies should be carried out according to the procedure of holding meetings, rallies, demonstrations, and peaceful processions prescribed by law.”

State control of religious expression extends to personal dress and grooming. In January 2014, Tajik Imams were issued new uniforms, and Abdulfattoh Shafiev wrote recently for Global Voices about several incidents of forced beard-shaving.

On March 31 a visitor to Khujand lost his way, and asked a local policeman how to find it again. The 38-year-old man, who grew a beard after a pilgrimage to the Kaaba five years ago, soon regretted his question.


He claims he was taken to a police station, beaten, and forcefully shaved.


As in the other former Soviet republics of Central Asia, the government of Tajikistan is fiercely secular while the people are mostly Muslim. The influence of Soviet communism on religion in the region should not be discounted, and fundamentally influences the relationship between people, their religion, and politics. In a paper published by Chatham House last November, John Heathershaw, and David W. Montgomery identify the claim that political Islam opposes the secular state as one of the six myths of post-Soviet Muslim radicalization in Central Asia. Myth or not, the worry that political Islam could challenge the establishment, persists.

This week, Interfax reported that the CRA said in a press conference that only people over the age of 35 would be among those permitted to perform the annual pilgrimage (hajj) to the Islamic holy sites at Medina and Mecca this year. CRA is responsible for registering those who wish to travel for hajj. Saudi Arabia, which establishes national quotas in order to regulate the overwhelming flood of faithful each year, has reportedly lowered Tajikistan’s quota from 8,000 to 6,300 people.

One way to view the Tajik government’s age restriction is practicality–this is an easy way to trim the applicant pool. But in light of other trends, and the government’s overwhelming fear of youth radicalization, the dictum feeds into a larger narrative chronicling Tajikistan’s crackdown on Islam.

-------------------------------------------------------------

Another shining example of a secular state with muslim majority. Believe it or not reportedly 95% of Tajikistan is sunni muslim but muslim men can't even have a beard under state law. There was an incident at the beginning of this year when 13,000 men were forcefully shaved by police. Tajikistan is just part of the century long secular crusade that is going on against the muslim world.


@Zarvan @Apprentice @Malik Abdullah @Aslan @Tipu7 @T-Rex @Al-zakir @tesla @Yellow-place @dsr478 @bsruzm @CrimsonFury @Zulkarneyn @HAKIKAT @Jamaal Yelmaaz @jamal18 @LeGenD @Arefin007 @Stannis Baratheon @asad71 @monitor @Psychic @kobiraaz @Indus Falcon @Djinn @lastofthepatriots @war&peace @Saiful Islam @django @Sparkle229 @Mrc @alarabi @Decisive Storm @Akheilos @Timur @naveedullahkhankhattak @Talwar e Pakistan @Major Sam
@Ghareeb_Da_Baal @hussain0216 @Azad-Kashmiri @Genghis khan1 @ThE-ShOwStOpPeR
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
well sometime you need to went ultra down to control heavy extremism . i think they are working on it . you know what ? tajikistan have border with afghanistan but no suicide bombing no jihad no mess like we are facing . this is called saving home from fire . other side we have lost 70000 lives and still confused taliban are our brothers or terrorists .
 
Hi,

I would rather have a minimum age limit of 40-45 years old for haj---one haj in lifetime---one Umrah.

People over a certain income level would have to donate a certain amount of money towards the states welfare funds---for performing haj or umrah.

Anyone known to have performed more than one Umrah without permission---will be fined 10 times their total expenditure of the trip.

People will be encouraged to donate their money for Hajj and Umrah towards the welfare of the poor---till the over all condition of the poor people improves.

Now for those who will gibve eamples of corruption---to them---if this was implemented---the corrupt would have been strung by their necks by now---so the fear of corruption would not be there.

A ' good muslim ' does not need a BEARD.
 
Last edited:
I don't know much about Tajikistan or their politics but

nefdik ya Rehmon ? :yahoo:


seriously though, on balance, sunni fundamentalism and militancy has proved to be a bigger problem for the nations and societies that birth these movements than anyone else, any crackdown on that kind of extremism, especially within the Islamic world, is a good step.
 
Instigation and oppression

Sometimes there is a legitimate reason to rise up and fight to be able to protect and practice your faith

Too many times we have people turn to violence too early when you have alternative options, but when you have a dictator who tries to break you down and stop you practicing your faith in your own land that your people have done for hundreds of years a legitimate reason emerges to rise up and fight that abuse

Tajikistan: No Hajj, No Hijab, and Shave Your Beard
In a Muslim-majority country, state control of religious expression tightens.

thediplomat_2015-04-16_15-42-51-386x257.jpg


Technically, freedom of religion is enshrined in the constitution of Tajikistan. But in reality, religious practice–at least for members of the country’s Muslim majority–is tightly controlled by the state. In recent months, Tajikistan has further steadied its grip on the practice of Islam with the president commenting on proper attire, reports of forced beard-shavings, and new regulations on who can travel to Mecca on hajj.

Until last month’s parliamentary elections, Tajikistan was the only Central Asian state in which political Islam had representation. The Islamic Renaissance Party of Tajikistan (IRPT) is widely touted as the only legally registered religious party in the region. While true, in the March election (unsurprisingly flawed) the IRPT lost, and for the first time since its legalization following the civil war will be out of government entirely. To add insult to injury the country’s official religious bodies have called for the IRPT to be banned, and some have suggested it should be labeled a terrorist organization.

The tightening grip of the state on Islam extends beyond politics. The State Committee on Religious Affairs (CRA) is responsible for overseeing and implementing laws relating to religion–including registration of religious groups, regulation of imports of religious materials, and oversight of mosques and churches. The Council of Ulema guides the Tajik Muslim community and while nominally independent, presents a state-approved version of Islam.

There are laws on the books banning female students from wearing hijabs, prohibiting those under the age of 18 from from participating in public religious activities, except funerals, which are regulated anyway. According to the U.S. Department of State’s 2013 International Religious Freedom Report:

The law regulates private celebrations and funeral services, including weddings and Mavludi Payghambar (the Prophet Muhammad’s birthday). The law limits the number of guests, eliminates engagement parties, and controls ceremonial gift presentations and other rituals. The religion law reiterates these principles, mandating that “mass worship, religious traditions, and ceremonies should be carried out according to the procedure of holding meetings, rallies, demonstrations, and peaceful processions prescribed by law.”

State control of religious expression extends to personal dress and grooming. In January 2014, Tajik Imams were issued new uniforms, and Abdulfattoh Shafiev wrote recently for Global Voices about several incidents of forced beard-shaving.

On March 31 a visitor to Khujand lost his way, and asked a local policeman how to find it again. The 38-year-old man, who grew a beard after a pilgrimage to the Kaaba five years ago, soon regretted his question.


He claims he was taken to a police station, beaten, and forcefully shaved.


As in the other former Soviet republics of Central Asia, the government of Tajikistan is fiercely secular while the people are mostly Muslim. The influence of Soviet communism on religion in the region should not be discounted, and fundamentally influences the relationship between people, their religion, and politics. In a paper published by Chatham House last November, John Heathershaw, and David W. Montgomery identify the claim that political Islam opposes the secular state as one of the six myths of post-Soviet Muslim radicalization in Central Asia. Myth or not, the worry that political Islam could challenge the establishment, persists.

This week, Interfax reported that the CRA said in a press conference that only people over the age of 35 would be among those permitted to perform the annual pilgrimage (hajj) to the Islamic holy sites at Medina and Mecca this year. CRA is responsible for registering those who wish to travel for hajj. Saudi Arabia, which establishes national quotas in order to regulate the overwhelming flood of faithful each year, has reportedly lowered Tajikistan’s quota from 8,000 to 6,300 people.

One way to view the Tajik government’s age restriction is practicality–this is an easy way to trim the applicant pool. But in light of other trends, and the government’s overwhelming fear of youth radicalization, the dictum feeds into a larger narrative chronicling Tajikistan’s crackdown on Islam.

-------------------------------------------------------------

Another shining example of a secular state with muslim majority. Believe it or not reportedly 95% of Tajikistan is sunni muslim but muslim mean can't even have a beard under state law. There was an incident at the beginning of this year when 13,000 men were forcefully shaved by police. Tajikistan is just part of the century long secular crusade that is going on against the muslim world.


@Zarvan @Apprentice @Malik Abdullah @Aslan @Tipu7 @T-Rex @Al-zakir @tesla @Yellow-place @dsr478 @bsruzm @CrimsonFury @Zulkarneyn @HAKIKAT @Jamaal Yelmaaz @jamal18 @LeGenD @Arefin007 @Stannis Baratheon @asad71 @monitor @Psychic @kobiraaz @Indus Falcon @Djinn @lastofthepatriots @war&peace @Saiful Islam @django @Sparkle229 @Mrc @alarabi @Decisive Storm @Akheilos @Timur @naveedullahkhankhattak @Talwar e Pakistan @Major Sam
@Akheilos @Ghareeb_Da_Baal @hussain0216 @Azad-Kashmiri

This is also part of the reason why we should be so anti secular

In our part of the world secular dosent mean separation of state and faith it means the forced oppression of muslims by pseudo atheists

Its why we as Muslims should be do vigilant and opposed to secularists
 
People going berserk over this news need to understand that Tajikistan was once ruled by an Atheist super power, after independence they faced civil war. It is obvious that many Tajiks would want to find their identity, some turn to nationalism and some turn to religion. Problem might arise if that brand of Islam is being funded from Saudia. That could mean Tajikistan will turn into another Afghanistan. I hope Tajikistan finds the right balance.
 
Ya Luffy, what do you think of the comments above from so called Muslims in my country?

Disgraceful but expected from secularists who have been intellectually colonized to hate Islam. Secularists in the muslim world are same everywhere. They are a virulent bunch designed to destroy the muslim world on behest of the western world.
 
The repression in this and other former cis countries have been totally ignored by the press. Literally these countries have been off the radar. Endless cases of human rights abuse, and totally ignored by the world.

Hi,

I would rather have a minimum age limit of 40-45 years old for haj---one haj in lifetime---one Umrah.

People over a certain income level would have to donate a certain amount of money towards the states welfare funds---for performing haj or umrah.

Anyone know to have performed more than one Umrah without permission---will be fined 10 times their total expenditure of the trip.

People will be encouraged to donate their money for Hajj and Umrah towards the welfare of the poor---till the over all condition of the poor people improves.

Now for those who will gibve eamples of corruption---to them---if this was implemented---the corrupt would have been strung by their necks by now---so the fear of corruption would not be there.

A ' good muslim ' does not need a BEARD.

Your going to decide this?

Let's forget Islam altogether. Get on our knees and worship Western man. Perhaps you can right a new koran?
Compulsory pork eating, ban on hijab and mixed nude saunas? I
 
Turkey should use its influence to make Tajik government have some sense.

After Soviet's fall---Islam has been regaining it's natural position of being the dominant socio-cultural religious force in central Asia. These despots of Central Asia fear an Islamist overthrow of their government like in Iran etc--or an Islamic political force taking complete control via democratic process (Turkey)---hence the repression.

They'll only make things worse.

Major central Asian countries as such Kazakhstan etc have dealt with this with more balanced approach. President and founder of Kazakhstan (largest nation of Central Asia) said how he is proud of Islam and his people/country are a part of Islamic tradition--but at the same time opposed what he viewed "Arabization" process etc...

But smaller Central Asian states are just nuts!

It's time wider Islamic World, OIC, Turkey etc take up this issue with these governments. We don't want a 'Muslim France' amongst our folds..
 

Back
Top Bottom