What's new

Russia slams US for its human rights record

53fd

FULL MEMBER

New Recruit

Joined
Jul 2, 2010
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
MOSCOW (AP) — Russia's Foreign Ministry has attacked America's human rights record in its first report on injustice elsewhere in the world, offering examples such as the Guantanamo Bay prison and wrongful death row convictions to paint the U.S. as hypocritical for lecturing other nations on the subject of rights.

"The situation in the United States is a far cry from the ideals that Washington proclaims," says the report released Wednesday.

Moscow has previously reacted angrily to the accusations of human rights breaches that the U.S. State Department has leveled at Russia in its annual reports. The State Department has expressed concern about the violent attacks on rights activists and journalists in Russia, most of which go unpunished. It also has criticized abuses in Russia's Caucasus, including extrajudicial killings, kidnappings and torture.

The 90-page Russian report slams EU nations, Canada and Georgia, but reserves its longest section of 20 pages for what it says are violations by the United States. The report does not cover Asia, Africa or the Middle East, other than a five-page section criticizing the NATO operation in Libya.

Moscow laments the ongoing operation of the "notorious" prison in Guantanamo Bay, where terrorism suspects have been held since the Sept. 11, 2001 attacks, and criticizes President Barack Obama for "legalizing indefinite and extrajudicial custody and the return of court martials."

The report accuses the U.S. of prying into citizens' personal lives and violating the rights of Muslim Americans in the fight against terrorism. It also points to errors made by American courts.

"Judicial errors are the Achilles heel of American justice as concerns capital punishment," the report argues. It notes the roughly 130 people sentenced to death in the past 30 years who were later cleared of the charges, some after they were executed.

The Foreign Ministry also struck back at international criticism of Russia's recent parliamentary election, which independent observers said involved widespread fraud. Outrage over the vote set off a spate of protests led by citizens unhappy with Vladimir Putin's rule.

The report accuses the U.S. of blocking independent candidates from elections and criticizes the practice of allowing governors to nominate senators when a Senate seat is vacated, as when Obama became president. It refers to the conviction this year of former Illinois Gov. Rod Blagojevich, who was accused of trying to auction off Obama's Senate seat.

The State Department is reviewing the Russian report, spokesman Mark Toner said. He said such reports can be a "useful mechanism provided that they are produced using objective methodology."
"We certainly don't regard it as interference in our internal affairs when foreign governments, individuals or organizations comment on or criticize U.S. human rights practices," he said, adding later, "In terms of our human rights record, we're an open book."

Russia slams US for its human rights record - Yahoo! News
 
Still it's better than HR anywhere else in the world ,save the Nordic countries
 
The Russian media and RT particularly were covering the OWS movement extensively. Then suddenly the protests in Moscow break out and Russia media is, well busy home. :P On the risk of sounding like a conspiracy theorist I can't help but allege - could US have something to do with it?

On a saner note, having lived in here for quite some time, I have to disagree with our dear friends in Moscow.

Pot slams kettle... :P

The right phrase would be "The pot calling the kettle black"!
 
While HR in the US are a lot better than many countries in the world, there has been a deliberate 'movement' in America to suppress individual liberties of the American people. In terms of foreign policy, the government initially needed to get authorization from the Congress to go to war (as per US constitution) in the past, but the (unconstitutional) War Powers Resolution that was passed overruled that. The Patriot Act & the new terror suspect law go against the principles of the US constitution as well. Tapping of the phone lines, internet monitoring is common as well.
 
OT: Whats up with Indians blindly defending US? :disagree: Seen in numerous threads, most of them seem like from US fanboys club.

Maybe they actually lived in US ?

US still has better HR record than most Asian/East European/Latin American countries. Less said about Africa the better.

It's nothing to do with blindly defending . Just saying the truth as it is. Also maybe there is no blind hate to the US.
 
Maybe they actually lived in US ?

US still has better HR record than most Asian/East European/Latin American countries. Less said about Africa the better.

It's nothing to do with blindly defending . Just saying the truth as it is. Also maybe there is no blind hate to the US.
Nonsense, US HR is definitely worse than a LOT of countries, not just Nordic. Its a fact, not opinion, like yours.
 
While HR in the US are a lot better than many countries in the world, there has been a deliberate 'movement' in America to suppress individual liberties of the American people. In terms of foreign policy, the government initially needed to get authorization from the Congress to go to war (as per US constitution) in the past, but the (unconstitutional) War Powers Resolution that was passed overruled that. The Patriot Act & the new terror suspect law go against the principles of the US constitution as well. Tapping of the phone lines, internet monitoring is common as well.

I've to disagree! The decision to go to war can't be turned into suppression of individual rights (which is probably different from human rights anyway).

Secondly, over and over it has been proven that Americans preferred security over liberty in the wake of barbaric 9/11 attacks by Islamic Fundamentalists and then the constant reminders by the Bush administration of an impending attack.

Its only now they've started criticizing the TSA! But the administration has to take into account people like faisal shahzad ready to blow up things!
 
Bl[i]tZ;2437885 said:
I've to disagree! The decision to go to war can't be turned into suppression of individual rights (which is probably different from human rights anyway).

The decision to go to war has to be authorized by the Congress, as specified by the US constitution. The War Powers Resolution was a direct violation to that. While you are right that this does not directly concern HR in America, it is one example I showed where the government is getting 'too big'. America was founded on America-the-people, & 'small' government.

Secondly, over and over it has been proven that Americans preferred security over liberty in the wake of barbaric 9/11 attacks by Islamic Fundamentalists and then the constant reminders by the Bush administration of an impending attack.

The actions taken by the administration since 9/11 have not made America safer, but more prone to threats of terrorist attacks.
 
Still no terrorist acts have been committed...No ?

That's not true. There have been a number of attacks against the US, but luckily, they were foiled & did not bear fruit. Some of them are:

December 2001, Richard Reid: British citizen attempted to ignite shoe bomb on flight from Paris to Miami.

• May 2002, Jose Padilla: American citizen accused of seeking radioactive-laced "dirty bomb" to use in an attack against Amrica. Padilla was convicted of conspiracy in August, 2007.

• September 2002, Lackawanna Six: American citizens of Yemeni origin convicted of supporting Al Qaeda after attending jihadist camp in Pakistan. Five of six were from Lackawanna, N.Y.

• Click to view photos of suspected terrorists and attack sites.

• May 2003, Iyman Faris: American citizen charged with plotting to use blowtorches to collapse the Brooklyn Bridge.

• June 2003, Virginia Jihad Network: Eleven men from Alexandria, Va., trained for jihad against American soldiers, convicted of violating the Neutrality Act, conspiracy.

• August 2004, Dhiren Barot: Indian-born leader of terror cell plotted bombings on financial centers (see additional images).

• August 2004, James Elshafay and Shahawar Matin Siraj: Sought to plant bomb at New York's Penn Station during the Republican National Convention.

• August 2004, Yassin Aref and Mohammed Hossain: Plotted to assassinate a Pakistani diplomat on American soil.

• June 2005, Father and son Umer Hayat and Hamid Hayat: Son convicted of attending terrorist training camp in Pakistan; father convicted of customs violation.

• August 2005, Kevin James, Levar Haley Washington, Gregory Vernon Patterson and Hammad Riaz Samana: Los Angeles homegrown terrorists who plotted to attack National Guard, LAX, two synagogues and Israeli consulate.

• December 2005, Michael Reynolds: Plotted to blow up natural gas refinery in Wyoming, the Transcontinental Pipeline, and a refinery in New Jersey. Reynolds was sentenced to 30 years in prison.

• February 2006, Mohammad Zaki Amawi, Marwan Othman El-Hindi and Zand Wassim Mazloum: Accused of providing material support to terrorists, making bombs for use in Iraq.

• April 2006, Syed Haris Ahmed and Ehsanul Islam Sadequee: Cased and videotaped the Capitol and World Bank for a terrorist organization.

• June 2006, Narseal Batiste, Patrick Abraham, Stanley Grant Phanor, Naudimar Herrera, Burson Augustin, Lyglenson Lemorin, and Rotschild Augstine: Accused of plotting to blow up the Sears Tower.

• July 2006, Assem Hammoud: Accused of plotting to bomb New York City train tunnels.

• August 2006, Liquid Explosives Plot: Thwarted plot to explode ten airliners over the United States.

• March 2007, Khalid Sheikh Mohammed: Mastermind of Sept. 11 and author of numerous plots confessed in court in March 2007 to planning to destroy skyscrapers in New York, Los Angeles and Chicago. Mohammedalso plotted to assassinate Pope John Paul II and former President Bill Clinton.

• May 2007, Fort Dix Plot: Six men accused of plotting to attack Fort Dix Army base in New Jersey. The plan included attacking and killing soldiers using assault rifles and grenades.

• June 2007, JFK Plot: Four men are accused of plotting to blow up fuel arteries that run through residential neighborhoods at JFK Airport in New York.

• September 2007, German authorities disrupt a terrorist cell that was planning attacks on military installations and facilities used by Americans in Germany. The Germans arrested three suspected members of the Islamic Jihad Union, a group that has links to Al Qaeda and supports Al Qaeda's global jihadist agenda.

Foiled Terror Plots Against America Since 9/11 | Fox News

As I said, America has not become safer since 9/11, there is more threat from terrorism, & attacks against the US than even before.
 

Back
Top Bottom