What's new

Rape Prevention

Gufi

RETIRED TTA
Joined
Dec 3, 2014
Messages
2,894
Reaction score
36
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
table 1.png
This following thread is a basis for constructive discussion, no trolling what so ever
Prevention: WHAT is the focus?
To prevent sexual violence, we have to understand what circumstances and factors influence its occurrence.
There are many different theoretical models that attempt to describe the root causes of sexual
violence: biological models, psychological models, cultural models, and grassroots, feminist, power-based
models. Each of these models contributes to a better understanding of sexual violence and helps experts
build programs that sustain protective factors and reduce modifiable risk factors. The CDC working group
(see inside front cover) chose to use an ecological model as part of the framework for our discussion
because it allows us to include risk and protective factors from multiple domains. Thus, if there is evidence
from psychological models about individual risk factors and from feminist models about societal risk
factors, it can all be incorporated in the same ecological model. Building such a model offers a framework
for understanding the complex interplay of individual, relationship, social, political, cultural, and environmental
factors that influence sexual violence (Dahlberg and Krug 2002) and also provides key points for
prevention and intervention (Powell, Mercy, Crosby, et al. 1999). We use the four-level ecological model
presented in the World Report on Violence and Health for this discussion (Dahlberg and Krug 2002);
however, there are a variety of ecological models that have been developed (see, for example, Heise
1998).
The examples in Table 1 illustrate the levels of the ecological model. The examples of risk factors are also
taken from the chapter on sexual violence in the World Report on Violence and Health (Jewkes, Sen,
Garcia-Moreno 2002) and are not a comprehensive list of risk factors for sexual violence perpetration.
There is a lack of research on protective factors so no such examples are presented in the model.
• Individual-level influences are biological and include personal history factors that increase the
likelihood that an individual will become a victim or perpetrator of violence. For example, factors
such as alcohol and/or drug use; attitudes and beliefs that support sexual violence; impulsive and
other antisocial tendencies; preference for impersonal sex; hostility towards women; and childhood
history of sexual abuse or witnessing family violence may influence an individual’s behavior
choices that lead to perpetration of sexual violence (Dahlberg and Krug 2002). Interventions for
individual-level influences are often designed to target social and cognitive skills and behavior and
include approaches such as counseling, therapy, and educational training sessions (Powell et al.
1999).
• Interpersonal relationship-level influences are factors that increase risk as a result of
relationships with peers, intimate partners, and family members. A person’s closest social circle—
peers, partners, and family members—can shape the individual’s behavior and range of experience
(Dahlberg and Krug 2002). Interventions for interpersonal relationship-level influences could
include family therapy, bystander intervention skill development, and parenting training (Powell et
al. 1999).
4
Individual Relationship Community Societal
Influences: attitudes and beliefs Influences: association Influences: general tolerance Influences: inequalities
that support sexual violence; with sexually aggressive of sexual assault; lack of based on gender, race,
impulsive and antisocial behavior; peers; family environment support from police or judicial and sexual orientation,
childhood history of sexual abuse that is emotionally system; poverty; lack of religious or cultural
or witnessing violence; alcohol unsupportive, physically employment opportunities; beliefs, economic and
and drug use violent or strongly weak community sanctions social policies
patriarchal against perpetrators

• Community-level influences are factors that increase risk based on community and social
environments and include an individual’s experiences and relationships with schools, workplaces,
and neighborhoods. For example, lack of sexual harassment policies in the workplace can send a
message that sexual harassment is tolerated, and that there may be few or no consequences for
those who harass others. Interventions for community-level influences are typically designed to
impact the climate, systems, and policies in a given setting.
• Societal-level influences are larger, macro-level factors that influence sexual violence such as
gender inequality, religious or cultural belief systems, societal norms, and economic or social
policies that create or sustain gaps and tensions between groups of people. For example, rape is
more common in cultures that promote male sexual entitlement and support an ideology of male
superiority (Dahlberg and Krug 2002). Interventions for societal-level influences typically involve
collaborations by multiple partners to change laws and policies related to sexual violence or
gender inequality. Another intervention would be to determine societal norms that accept violence
and to identify strategies for changing those norms (Powell et al. 1999).
The ecological model supports a comprehensive public health approach that not only addresses an
individual’s risk factors, but also the norms, beliefs, and social and economic systems that create the
conditions for the occurrence of sexual violence.
Table 1. The Ecological Model
 
Prevention: Integrating the WHEN and the WHAT
The following matrix provides examples of how interventions to prevent violence before it occurs, and
interventions that take place after violence has happened, can be implemented across all levels of the
ecological model. Distinguishing interventions by “before” and “after” violence has occurred serves to
highlight the salient differences between the two approaches.
table 2.png


Prevention: WHO is it for?
Prevention strategies are often developed based upon the group for whom the intervention is intended.
Using this type of differentiation, sexual violence interventions can again be divided into three categories:
• Approaches that are aimed at groups or the general population regardless of individual risk for
sexual violence perpetration or victimization are called universal interventions. Groups can be
defined geographically (e.g., entire school or school district) or by characteristics (e.g., ethnicity,
age, gender).
• Approaches that are aimed at those who are thought to have a heightened risk for sexual
violence perpetration or victimization are referred to as selected interventions.
• Approaches that are aimed at those who have already perpetrated sexual violence or have been
victimized are called indicated interventions.

Prevention: Integrating the WHAT and the WHO
The following matrix demonstrates how universal, selected, and indicated approaches can be implemented across the ecological model. Comprehensive prevention programs are multifaceted and address multiple cells within the matrix. CDC acknowledges that some of the programs and services designed for victims may also prevent reoccurrences of victimization and perpetration. However, we still consider these activities “indicated” because the primary goal of many of these programs is to address the important need to prevent the short- and long-term negative consequences of the violence. As a primary goal, the public health community wants to prevent new incidents from occurring, so in keeping with this, we have provided some examples of strategies and activities for both universal and selected approaches within the ecological model. It is important to note that the cells in the matrix are not isolated from one another and may overlap. For example, women could be defined as an entire population for a universal approach or as a high-risk group for a selected approach. Either approach could be appropriate, but the course of action taken should be based on data or other considerations outlined in “How to Make Programmatic Decisions about Prevention Approaches” on page 10. Because this document is geared toward the RPE program, no examples for indicated approaches were included.

Table 3. The WHAT and WHO Matrix
NOTE: The example strategies in this matrix further describe prevention concepts and strategies.
CDC looks forward to working with grantees to develop innovative and effective ways to prevent
sexual violence that address individual, relationship, community, and societal influences for universal
and selected populations.

table 3
table 3.png


table 4a.png


table 5.png


Making Programmatic Decisions About Prevention Approaches
None of the categories presented within the matrix (i.e., the what and who of prevention) are superior to the others. In fact, each has its own advantages and disadvantages (Powell et al. 1999). Universal, selected, and indicated interventions all contribute to a comprehensive prevention strategy.

1.Educational seminars
2.Hotlines
3.Training programs for professionals
4.Informational materials
5.Training programs for students and campus personnel designed to reduce the incidence of sexual assault at colleges and universities
6.Education to increase awareness about drugs used to facilitate rape or sexual assault
7.Other efforts to increase awareness in underserved communities and awareness

References
1.Dahlberg LL, Krug EG. Violence – a global public health problem. In: Krug EG, Dahlberg LL, Mercy JA, Zwi AB, Lozano R, editors. World Report on Violence and Health. Geneva (Switzerland): World Health Organization; 2002. p. 3-21.
2.Heise LL Violence against women: an integrated, ecological framework. Violence Against Women 1998;4(Pt 3), 262-90.
3.Jewkes R, Sen P, Garcia-Moreno C. Sexual violence. In: Krug EG, Dahlberg LL, Mercy JA, Zwi AB, Lozano R, editors. World Report on Violence and Health. Geneva (Switzerland): World Health Organization; 2002. p. 149-81.
4.Krug EG, Dahlberg LL, Mercy JA, Zwi AB, Lozano R, editors. World Report on Violence and Health. Geneva (Switzerland): World Health Organization; 2002.
5.Mercy JA, Rosenberg ML, Powell KE, Broome CV, Roper WL. Public health policy for preventing violence. Health Affairs 1993; 7-29.
6.Powell KE, Mercy JA, Crosby AE, Dahlberg LL, Simon TR. Public health models of violence and violence prevention. In: Kurtz LR, editors. Encyclopedia of Violence, Peace, and Conflict.
Vol. 3. San Diego (CA): Academic Press;1999:175-87.
13
@Nihonjin1051 @janon @SpArK @Slav Defence @Horus @syedali73
This thread is for brainstorming using CDC plans to see how as nations we can use these methods to prevent rape in our societies. Rather then mud slinging it is time we take a constructive attitude.
@Nihonjin1051 Understanding the human mind better then most of us I believe you can help with your analysis I would be grateful for your input

PS this is an extract some medical things I have left out as they are not relevant and can lead to detraction of the thread.

@RescueRanger sir your output on policing reforms would be appreciated
@levina a mature outlook please on your thoughts
@Akheilos
@SvenSvensonov your research even if it is not your field would be appreciated.
@Blue_Eyes I would appreciate constructive views
Anyone is welcome to join which is why I did not post in Seniors cafe but rather here so we can have healthy points given with no bashing. There are moderators here to keep an eye on things and any trolling is not allowed.

@jamahir some constructive points we disagree on many things but you do think outside the box and can come up with good ideas

@waz please read and give me your opinion and keep an eye on this thread

@TankMan

@Chronos
 
Last edited:
@Gufi looks fine bro and informative. I just deleted four other rape threads.....:rolleyes:
The whole purpose of this thread is to find constructive points to improve the problem rather then fight like little children and result in threads which end up in India Pakistan who is worse. Please read and give constructive feedback, many prevention courses are taught in universities in UK and you may be able to give a good basis on where to start from
 
Gud effort:tup:
but effective implementation of such strategies on a large scale in 3rd world countries will be difficult due to various reasons.
I feel more emphasis shud be given on making ppl believe that its impossible to get away with it.
ridiculously harsh punishments n fast tracking such cases in court of law can do wonders.
 
Last edited:
Gud effort:tup:
but effective implementation of such strategies on a large scale in 3rd world countries will be difficult due to various reasons.
I feel more emphasis shud be given on making ppl believe that its impossible to get away with it.
ridiculously harsh punishments n fast tracking such cases in court of law can do wonders.
agree with your post but we always tend to focus on the 3rd world when talking of social ills such as rape but interestingly it's Sweden with the highest percentage (at least according to this chart from a few years ago)

Rape_rate_per_100%2C000_-_country_comparison_-_United_Nations_2012.png

and look at some of the others on the list: New Zealand, Belgium, USA, Norway, Finland....
 
agree with your post but we always tend to focus on the 3rd world when talking of social ills such as rape but interestingly it's Sweden with the highest percentage (at least according to this chart from a few years ago)

Rape_rate_per_100%2C000_-_country_comparison_-_United_Nations_2012.png

and look at some of the others on the list: New Zealand, Belgium, USA, Norway, Finland....

That's not incorrect, but it's not entirely true either. Yes, Sweden does have the highest reported number of rapes... BUT, its definition of rape is more stringent too. For most nations, rape is penetrative or oral, for Sweden, all illicit and unsolicited touching of another persons - you know, will constitute rape in the judicial system.

It's a much more stringent definition that artificially inflates the overall number of reported rapes. How many involved the US or Indian or Japanese standards and definition of rape? Far fewer cases than reported.

In Sweden, the definition of rape has been successively widened over the years, leading to an ever larger number of sexual assaults being classified as rape.

Rape in Sweden - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

The graph is good, but like many graphs it lacks perspective.
 
Last edited:
@Gufi and all see this video-
the experts who are commenting in this video are better than us in this subject, you will find out, whats the problem and how can it be solved. (the debate is based on a particular rape case but it reflects the condition of almost all rape cases)
 
That's not incorrect, but it's not entirely true either. Yes, Sweden does have the highest reported number of rapes... BUT, its definition of rape is more stringent too. For most nations, rape is penetrative or oral, for Sweden, all illicit and unsolicited touching of another persons - you know, will constitute rape in the judicial system.

It's a much more stringent definition that artificially inflates the overall number of reported rapes. How many involved the US or Indian stands and definition of rape? Far fewer cases than reported.

In Sweden, the definition of rape has been successively widened over the years, leading to an ever larger number of sexual assaults being classified as rape.

Rape in Sweden - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

The graph is good, but like many graphs it lacks perspective.
right, I didn't know that. It did strike me as very strange to see a country like that topping stats like these.

they should drop the case against Julian Assange and let the man live in peace :mad:
 
o_O:coffee: When there is lack of weapon purchase thread like this get posted so depressing

My rape prevention guidelines

1- No short short skirt , with Katrina Kaif promotion in movies, 80 sal ka bhuddah bhi jooshila ho
jaiga
2- No item girl songs in movies , vulgar songs, these song just encourage rude behavior
3- Reduction of rape scenes in movies
4- Control on Bollywood , and their low moral values in movies for last 20 years
5- Adaption of more libral approach in highschools, as in west reduces sexual frustration
6- Common sense , by women to not be walking around in evening to be in bad situation
Keep a licence gun if needed :sniper:, just make sure you don't use it on your ex boyfriend


Lately every new indian movie song is sexually charged up sometimes highly inappropriate for family setting , no wonder there is rise in sexual violence due to sexual frustration

The graph level of movies with high skin and sexual content has risen dramatically last 15-20 years
 
Last edited:
o_O:coffee: When there is lack of weapon purchase thread like this get posted so depressing

My rape prevention guidelines

1- No short short skirt , with Katrina Kaif promotion in movies, 80 sal ka bhuddah bhi jooshila ho
jaiga
2- No item girl songs in movies , vulgar songs, these song just encourage rude behavior
3- Reduction of rape scenes in movies
4- Control on Bollywood , and their low moral values in movies for last 20 years
5- Adaption of more libral approach in highschools, as in west reduces sexual frustration
6- Common sense , by women to not be walking around in evening to be in bad situation
Keep a licence gun if needed :sniper:, just make sure you don't use it on your ex boyfriend


Lately every new indian movie song is sexually charged up sometimes highly inappropriate for family setting , no wonder there is rise in sexual violence due to sexual frustration

The graph level of movies with high skin and sexual content has risen dramatically last 15-20 years
Impement this in your country and see your men disaster pervert !
 
o_O:coffee: When there is lack of weapon purchase thread like this get posted so depressing

My rape prevention guidelines

1- No short short skirt , with Katrina Kaif promotion in movies, 80 sal ka bhuddah bhi jooshila ho
jaiga
2- No item girl songs in movies , vulgar songs, these song just encourage rude behavior
3- Reduction of rape scenes in movies
4- Control on Bollywood , and their low moral values in movies for last 20 years
5- Adaption of more libral approach in highschools, as in west reduces sexual frustration
6- Common sense , by women to not be walking around in evening to be in bad situation
Keep a licence gun if needed :sniper:, just make sure you don't use it on your ex boyfriend


Lately every new indian movie song is sexually charged up sometimes highly inappropriate for family setting , no wonder there is rise in sexual violence due to sexual frustration

The graph level of movies with high skin and sexual content has risen dramatically last 15-20 years
Bollywood ko control karnay say pehlay
Rachel Gill
Ahsan-Hussain-High-Fashion-Line-2013-2014-Rachel-Gill-2.jpg

Jia Ali
Jia%2BAli%2BHOT%2B4.png

Hamara bhe yahe haal hay boss nudity sells
 

Latest posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom