What's new

Pakistan apprehensive of US-India defence deal

Devil Soul

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Jun 28, 2010
Messages
22,931
Reaction score
45
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Pakistan apprehensive of US-India defence deal
By Reuters / Kamran Yousaf
Published: August 31, 2016
78SHARES
SHARE TWEET
PHOTO: AFP

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan is assessing the possible ramifications of an agreement signed between the United States and India that would allow the two countries to use each other’s land, air and naval bases even though Washington assured Islamabad that the military logistics pact would not jeopardise the country’s strategic interests.

The agreement signed by US Defence Secretary Ashton Carter and his Indian counterpart Manohar Parikar on Monday is seen as part of efforts by the two countries to counter the growing maritime assertiveness of China, especially in the South China Sea.

Kerry calls for more efforts to purge Pakistan of militancy

Although there was no official reaction yet from Pakistan, officials privately admitted that the Indo-US agreement could alter the strategic balance in the already volatile region.

Officials said the concerned authorities were looking into the details of the agreement and its possible negative fall interests as well as national security.’

The development comes at a time when relations between Pakistan and India are strained by the ongoing violence in Indian-controlled Kashmir.

It also coincides with a period in which Islamabad is increasingly concerned over a series of recent decisions by Washington to block military assistance as well as funds to purchase of F-16 fighter jets.

Last week senior US officials travelled to Islamabad to address Pakistan’s concerns over the defence pact, according to diplomatic sources.

Sources added that Special Assistant to the US President and Senior Director for South Asia Dr Peter Lavoy and US Special Representative to Pakistan and Afghanistan Richard Olson assured Pakistani authorities that Indo-US agreement would not hurt Islamabad’s interests.

US, India sign agreement to share military assets, bases

However, background discussions with officials in Islamabad suggested that Pakistan was left unconvinced and considers the pact with great ‘concerns and suspicion.’

Independent observers also believe that the agreement would irk China and Pakistan, who are currently working on $46 billion CPEC project that apparently upsets both Washington and New Delhi.

Officially, China on Tuesday offered a guarded reaction to the agreement.

“We have noted the relevant report. Hope that this cooperation between India and the US would work to promote stability and development of the region,” Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson Hua Chunying said in response to a question about the Indo-US Logistics Exchange Memorandum of Agreement (LEMOA).

“For such normal cooperation between the two sides we are glad to see it happen,” she added.

However, an editorial in the Chinese state-run Global Times titled “Is India heading toward alliance with US?” urged India not to give up its neutrality.

“Due to its non-alignment policy, India has been given attention from all the major powers such as the US, Japan, China and Russia in recent years. Now is arguably a time when India has the most room for strategic manoeuvring.”

Uncle Sam’s tight India embrace

But the daily warned that a hasty alliance with the US could undermine Indian security instead of bolstering it.

“If India hastily joins the US alliance system, it may irritate China, Pakistan or even Russia. It may not make India feel safer, but will bring strategic troubles to itself and make itself a centre of geopolitical rivalries in Asia.”

No US bases in India

The agreement signed between US and India on Monday will only govern the use of each other’s land, air and naval bases for repair and resupply but does not foresee exclusive bases.

The agreement, a relatively mundane one concerning day-to-day military logistics, is considered a milestone in the US-India defense relationship because of the outsized political importance it had taken on in India. But both Carter and Parrikar clarified that the agreement did not allow for basing US troops in India.

“It’s not a basing agreement of any kind,” Carter said. “It doesn’t have anything to do with the setting up of base. It’s basically logistics support to each other’s fleet, like supply of fuel, supply of many other things which are required for joint operations, humanitarian assistance and many other relief operations,” Parrikar added.

Published in The Express Tribune, August 31st, 2016.
 
They should be!

Although there was no official reaction yet from Pakistan, officials privately admitted that the Indo-US agreement could alter the strategic balance in the already volatile region.
Really? What 'strategic balance' are they talking about? There never was, is, nor will there ever be a 'strategic balance' with Pakistan! There's no comparison between the two. India is way way ahead.

However, background discussions with officials in Islamabad suggested that Pakistan was left unconvinced and considers the pact with great ‘concerns and suspicion.’
Ok. So what is Pakistan going to do about it? Order the US and India to cancel the deal just because they are 'concerned' and 'suspicious'? Pfffttt!

Independent observers also believe that the agreement would irk China and Pakistan, who are currently working on $46 billion CPEC project that apparently upsets both Washington and New Delhi.
We love irking and upsetting Pakistan and China. It feels good! :P :D

Officially, China on Tuesday offered a guarded reaction to the agreement.
'Guarded' reaction? Hmmmm....We thought the self styled supah powah would come out with all guns blazing! They seem to have run out of gas, what? :cheesy:

“Due to its non-alignment policy, India has been given attention from all the major powers such as the US, Japan, China and Russia in recent years. Now is arguably a time when India has the most room for strategic manoeuvring.”
That's exactly what the Modi government has been doing since the last two years! :-) And that's pissed off a couple of countries - no prizes for guessing which! ;)

“If India hastily joins the US alliance system, it may irritate China and Pakistan. It may not make India feel safer, but will bring strategic troubles to itself and make itself a centre of geopolitical rivalries in Asia.”
Like....grapes are sour? And.... 'Irritate'? Oh yeah! That's the whole point - to irritate! :D
 
Pakistan apprehensive of US-India defence deal
Although there was no official reaction yet from Pakistan, officials privately admitted that the Indo-US agreement could alter the strategic balance in the already volatile region.

Source: https://defence.pk/threads/pakistan-apprehensive-of-us-india-defence-deal.446867/#ixzz4IvedCTRc
Published in The Express Tribune, August 31st, 2016.

The balance is in favor of India. Access to limited amounts of sophisticated American hardware is going to end any Pakistani mischief making
 
They should be!


Really? What 'strategic balance' are they talking about? There never was, is, nor will there ever be a 'strategic balance' with Pakistan! There's no comparison between the two. India is way way ahead.


Ok. So what is Pakistan going to do about it? Order the US and India to cancel the deal just because they are 'concerned' and 'suspicious'? Pfffttt!


We love irking and upsetting Pakistan and China. It feels good! :P :D


'Guarded' reaction? Hmmmm....We thought the self styled supah powah would come out with all guns blazing! They seem to have run out of gas, what? :cheesy:


That's exactly what the Modi government has been doing since the last two years! :-) And that's pissed off a couple of countries - no prizes for guessing which! ;)


Like....grapes are sour? And.... 'Irritate'? Oh yeah! That's the whole point - to irritate! :D

Im not sure we care,

Seriously
 
I don't agree with that. We worked hard to reach where we are. You guys just played around with Islamic extremism to get thing done in your favor.
Not really. Thats just typical empty rhetoric. You guys had everything from beginning when british left. While Pakistan struggled to get even pens and papers for its first day at office. Indian parliament and everything was just left by whites ready to be occupied next by you lot. In terms of industries your TATA was already building fighter jets for Royal air force
 
And yet still, Pakistan exists

Your nation and their leaders should do some reality and priority check .
Is this is your benchmark ?
After all we are still exists even if spend all resources and fortune to irritate a big neighbour out there.:D


On topic :There is no strategic balance in here .India won that game around four decades agao.

Americans can use our bases in peace time under our control no more ,no less .Deal will nullify during war time .

Not really. Thats just typical empty rhetoric. You guys had everything from beginning when british left. While Pakistan struggled to get even pens and papers for its first day at office. Indian parliament and everything was just left by whites ready to be occupied next by you lot. In terms of industries your TATA was already building fighter jets for Royal air force

TATA and other engineering giants are nothing until 1991 liberalistation .
The so called mighty IT established only after 1991 .
A sector that gives us more than half of revenues of total GDP.
 
Your nation and their leaders should do some reality and priority check .
Is this is your benchmark ?
After all we are still exists even if spend all resources and fortune to irritate a big neighbour out there
Its a shame to put all the blame on your neighbour who is 1/6th of your size, don't ya think ? You cannot completely disregard the babu mentality in govt \. No, is not the benchmark, but it sure gives us hope that even after getting divided into thank to Indian support and our stupid policies we are still here to stay and we shall continue to exist, though we were not given proper breathing space.
 
And yet still, Pakistan exists

i cannot speak for all Indians. we do not decide if pakistan exists or not

Not really. Thats just typical empty rhetoric. You guys had everything from beginning when british left. While Pakistan struggled to get even pens and papers for its first day at office. Indian parliament and everything was just left by whites ready to be occupied next by you lot. In terms of industries your TATA was already building fighter jets for Royal air force

the industrial base left by the British was significant. but it is miniscule for the population
 
Its a shame to put all the blame on your neighbour who is 1/6th of your size, don't ya think ? You cannot completely disregard the babu mentality in govt \. No, is not the benchmark, but it sure gives us hope that even after getting divided into thank to Indian support and our stupid policies we are still here to stay and we shall continue to exist, though we were not given proper breathing space.

the babu mentality was courtesy of the British. it is hard to shake off
 

Back
Top Bottom