What's new

Pakistan And India-Water Disputes-News And Updates

shortburstinfo.blogspot.com/2013/01/pakistans-most-critical-issue.html

Ask a common Pakistani about the most critical issue of Pakistan, an astonishing 90% would give a single word answer, Zardari. A problem that alas has no end in sight, Zardari will be replaced by his likes from the dirty pool of Pakistani Politics, most hope for Imran Khan, a new face with new hope.

The most critical issue of Pakistan is not Zardari or our politicians in general, they are just a part of a bigger problem, that is fresh water. Fresh Water which produces Pakistan's 40% electricity, provides for agriculture which in turns provides 90%+ food & fiber, most raw materials for our industries (in the shape of cotton etc) and most essentially, the water we need to drink. In very accurate phrase, Pakistan won't survive without water.

Is something happening to water?

A lot is happening and a few times the media has also highlighted the issue but things get jumbled in between the many happenings in the country, from Veena Malik to Tahir-ul-Qadri, to the escalation on the borders. The armed forces are too busy protecting the borders and the politicians & bureaucrats busy playing "Zardari Zardari". The whole issue is the violation of the Indus water treaty.

The water from the Indus basin is distributed into two streams, western & eastern. The Western stream comprises of three rivers Indus, Jhelum & Chenab on which Pakistan has exclusive rights, while India has more or less exclusive rights over Eastern stream. As India need for water grew they built dams & diverted rivers on the western stream of Indus basin (violation of Indus Water treaty), which brings India in control of the Indus Basin waters, Pakistan’s primary source of freshwater source.

On top of it the supply from Indus has reduced considerably in the last decade, coupled with the use of water by India thins the supply of water to Pakistan.

What is Pakistan doing about it?



Chairman Pakistan Indus Water Commission, Jamat Ali Shah, the person responsible for not highlighting the issue when the dam was being constructed succeeded in escaping to Canada last year, despite his name being in the 'Exit control List'. The Government is in general not that interested to tackle the issue, they are too busy protecting their behinds. The armed forces are too focused on not getting them involved in politics.

That leaves Social societies & Individuals. A handful of people are protesting and highlighting the issue but nothing actionable is being done. On the positive side, Pakistan Business Council is taking action on the issue, what they can & cannot do is a question we all want answers for. Anatol Lieven in his book Pakistan: A hard Country highlighted water, as being the only issue that is threatening the existence of Pakistan. Majid Nizami Editor in Chief of The Nation daily newspaper advised Pakistanis to get themselves ready for war with India on water issue.

A war with India can be considered an extreme scenario but the questions we all should ask is

Can we survive without Indus?
 
1)Pakistan needs to construct more water reserviors.
2)Pakistan should take indus water treaty violations by india to international court of justice.
3)Pakistan should rapidly construct Neelum-Jehlum project.
4)Pakistan should take necessary steps in order to safe the already existing water from pollution.
 
Since Indians are getting too comfortable here, I'll troll a little :D

Pakistan's 9 dash line:

indian_ocean.gif

I will troll too.
india will dash this line.:P
 
shortburstinfo.blogspot.com/2013/01/pakistans-most-critical-issue.html

Ask a common Pakistani about the most critical issue of Pakistan, an astonishing 90% would give a single word answer, Zardari. A problem that alas has no end in sight, Zardari will be replaced by his likes from the dirty pool of Pakistani Politics, most hope for Imran Khan, a new face with new hope.

The most critical issue of Pakistan is not Zardari or our politicians in general, they are just a part of a bigger problem, that is fresh water. Fresh Water which produces Pakistan's 40% electricity, provides for agriculture which in turns provides 90%+ food & fiber, most raw materials for our industries (in the shape of cotton etc) and most essentially, the water we need to drink. In very accurate phrase, Pakistan won't survive without water.

Is something happening to water?

A lot is happening and a few times the media has also highlighted the issue but things get jumbled in between the many happenings in the country, from Veena Malik to Tahir-ul-Qadri, to the escalation on the borders. The armed forces are too busy protecting the borders and the politicians & bureaucrats busy playing "Zardari Zardari". The whole issue is the violation of the Indus water treaty.

The water from the Indus basin is distributed into two streams, western & eastern. The Western stream comprises of three rivers Indus, Jhelum & Chenab on which Pakistan has exclusive rights, while India has more or less exclusive rights over Eastern stream. As India need for water grew they built dams & diverted rivers on the western stream of Indus basin (violation of Indus Water treaty), which brings India in control of the Indus Basin waters, Pakistan’s primary source of freshwater source.

On top of it the supply from Indus has reduced considerably in the last decade, coupled with the use of water by India thins the supply of water to Pakistan.

What is Pakistan doing about it?



Chairman Pakistan Indus Water Commission, Jamat Ali Shah, the person responsible for not highlighting the issue when the dam was being constructed succeeded in escaping to Canada last year, despite his name being in the 'Exit control List'. The Government is in general not that interested to tackle the issue, they are too busy protecting their behinds. The armed forces are too focused on not getting them involved in politics.

That leaves Social societies & Individuals. A handful of people are protesting and highlighting the issue but nothing actionable is being done. On the positive side, Pakistan Business Council is taking action on the issue, what they can & cannot do is a question we all want answers for. Anatol Lieven in his book Pakistan: A hard Country highlighted water, as being the only issue that is threatening the existence of Pakistan. Majid Nizami Editor in Chief of The Nation daily newspaper advised Pakistanis to get themselves ready for war with India on water issue.

A war with India can be considered an extreme scenario but the questions we all should ask is

Can we survive without Indus?

No, you should be thankiing your lucky stars that Stupid, Idiotic Nehru was willing to give away 80% of the indus water (based on volume) instead of a common sense 50-50 split. You should be hoping the Indian citizens don't wake up to this idiocy and ask to rectify the treaty.

This brings us the question of whether Pakistanis who whine about the indus waters are ignorant of the facts or simply greedy bastards longing for the days of muslim empire in the subcontinent?
 
General Anthony Zinni (retd) of the United satates Army said, we have seen fuel wars, weare about to see water wars. While the indus Water Treaty 19 sep 1960 has provide a good frame work to both India and Pakistan for issues relating to water sharing for decades,
follow the reality
 
Pakistan close to being ‘water scarce’ country, says Asian Bank

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan is on the verge of being classified as a “water scarce” country, the Asian Development Bank has warned in a report.



Pakistan, which has failed to construct any major water reservoir for the last over 40 years besides facing Indian aggression on the water front, is said to have the storage capacity of only 30-day supply as against the recommended 1,000 days for countries with similar climate.



This situation, official sources said, is also very threatening for the agriculture output, which is the backbone of the country’s economy, and requires immediate attention of the government to address the issue of water management and building of additional reservoirs.



Th water and power ministry sources said that over the dismal situation of water in Pakistan, the Asian Development Outlook 2013 report said, “Pakistan is one of the most water-stressed countries in the world, not far from being classified as ‘water scarce,’ with less than 1,000 cubic meters per person per year.”



It added, “Water demand exceeds supply, which has caused maximum withdrawal from reservoirs. At present, Pakistan’s storage capacity is limited to a 30-day supply, well below the recommended 1,000 days for countries with a similar climate. Climate change is affecting snowmelt and reducing flows into the Indus River, the main supply source.”



The ADB recommended, “Increases in storage capacity to manage periods of low snowmelt and low rainfall are required, as well as the rehabilitation of the distribution system to reduce losses.” While the policy makers in Pakistan have turned blind eye to this serious challenge the ADB warned that without proper water management the agriculture sector of the country would also suffer badly. It said, “Achieving the major challenge of boosting agricultural productivity and strengthening food security requires improving the management, storage, and pricing of water for irrigation.”



In case of improved water management and storage capacity, the ADB said, “Anecdotal evidence suggests that agricultural productivity could be doubled with appropriate reform.”



The report added, “Improved water management is critical to deliver sufficient water to the 80% of farmland in the country that is irrigated”.



Only recently minister for planning and development Ahsan Iqbal was quoted to have said that there is no water scarcity in the country. He admitted that water resources are not managed properly to overcome water related issues. The minister said that Pakistan is going to face critical water management crisis. He said when Pakistan was created the per capita water availability in the country was 5000 cubic meters while in near future it would be as low as 800 cubic meters per capita.



Ahsan Iqbal said that Pakistan will have to enhance water storage capacity to meet water related issues.
 
So Lets Be Clear & Frank Pakistan Is Almost At End I Read Through The Thread. What Is Their Left To Do?? There Is No Water There Is No Life!!
 
Wasn't the ADB recommendation that Pakistan should manage water better? That surely is within Pakistan's control completely?
 
Wasn't the ADB recommendation that Pakistan should manage water better? That surely is within Pakistan's control completely?

The Indus river water treaty is straight forward. It gives three rivers to India (Beas,Satlej, ravi) and three rivers to Pakistan (Indus, Jhelum & Chenab). The three rivers awarded to Pakistan have an exception. waters are allowed for local use of Indian state of Jammu & Kashmir. As the population of Jammu and Kashmir increases look for the water amount going to Pakistan decreasing. It will set up a nice confrontation with Kashmiris whose interest Pakistan claims to espouse.
 
:pakistan:India you are the water theft we know that and you people are scared because you people started war on border so now get ready for India troops going to die!

Pakistan Zindaabad!
 
:pakistan:India you are the water theft we know that and you people are scared because you people started war on border so now get ready for India troops going to die!

Pakistan Zindaabad!
Instead of emotional rhetoric, I would like to ask you to read the complete text of Indus river treaty and dispute resolving mechanism part of the agreement. Once you have finished educating yourself on this subject than we will debate with you based on facts.
 

Back
Top Bottom