Another Test Failure for Russia's Bulava Missile
MOSCOW -
Russia's new nuclear-capable missile suffered another failed test launch, the defence ministry said Dec. 10, solving the mystery of a spectacular plume of white light that appeared over Norway.
AN UNUSUAL LIGHT phenomenon is seen Dec. 9 above the Norwegian city of Skjeroy. Its source was initially not known, but it was later found to be from a failed Russian missile launch. (ANITA OLSEN / SCANPIX / AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE)
The Bulava missile was test-fired from the submarine Dmitry Donskoi in the White Sea early Dec. 9 but failed at the third stage, the defence ministry said in a statement.
The predawn morning launch coincided with the appearance of an extraordinary light over northern Norway that captivated observers.
Images of the light that appeared in the sky above the Norwegian city of Tromso and elsewhere prompted explanations ranging from a meteor, northern lights, a failed missile or even a UFO.
Describing the latest failure of the Bulava as a major embarrassment for the military, leading Russian defense analyst Pavel Felgenhauer said the images were consistent with a missile failure.
"Such lights and clouds appear from time to time when a missile fails in the upper layers of the atmosphere and have been reported before," he told AFP.
"At least this failed test made some nice fireworks for the Norwegians," he joked.
The White Sea, which is the usual site for such missile tests by Russian submarines, lies close to Norway's own Arctic region.
This was the 12th test launch of the Bulava and the seventh time the firing has ended in failure, the Interfax news agency said.
The submarine-launched missile is central to Russia's plan to revamp its aging weapons arsenal but is beset by development problems.
"
The first two stages of the rocket worked, but in the final and third stage there was a technical failure," the defence ministry said in a statement.
The statement said the
problem was with the engine in the third stage, while in past launches the first stage had been faulty.
The problems with the Bulava have become an agonizing issue for the defence ministry, which has ploughed a large proportion of its procurement budget into ensuring the missile becomes the key element of its rocket forces.
The previous failure in July forced the resignation of Yury Solomonov, the director of the Moscow Institute of Thermal Technology, which is responsible for developing the missile.
Felgenhauer said that it had dealt a serious blow to Russia's bid to maintain a credible nuclear deterrent.
"
By the year 2030, Russia could lose its position as a global nuclear power if the problems are not solved. And it could be that these missiles will never fly properly.
"The Russian defense industry has disintegrated to such an extent that it simply cannot make such a complicated system work. Technology and expertise have been lost," he said.
He said there was significant opposition within the Russian defense establishment to the Bulava, meaning that information about its failures would always be impossible to conceal.
The problems are also a major political embarrassment, coming as Russia negotiates with the United States the parameters of a new arms reduction treaty to replace the 1991 START accord.
The treaty expired Dec. 5 and, despite intense negotiations, the two sides have yet to agree the text of a new deal.
The Bulava, which can be equipped with up to 10 individually targeted nuclear warheads, has a maximum range of 5,000 miles.
It is the sea-based version of the Topol-M, Russia's new surface-to-surface intercontinental missile, and designed to be launched from Moscow's newest Borei class of submarines.
Defense analysts say that a further headache for the military is that the new submarines are designed to be compatible with Bulava, and if the new missile fails to work the vessels will be virtually useless.
