What's new

Israel helped India in 1971 war: book

Hafizzz

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jun 28, 2010
Messages
5,041
Reaction score
0
http://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/israel-helped-india-in-1971-war-book/article1-1146011.aspx

ndia may not have had diplomatic ties with Israel but New Delhi quietly sought and got arms from Tel Aviv as it prepared to go to war with Pakistan in 1971, a book has revealed.
The book, 1971, by scholar Srinath Raghavan offers fresh insights into the 14-day war that led to the creation of Bangladesh.

Raghavan accessed the PN Haksar papers maintained at the Nehru Memorial Museum and Library in Delhi. These papers document startling aspects of a war that is probably India’s finest military moment but has not been documented adequately. A diplomat, Haksar was also an adviser to the then Prime Minister Indira Gandhi.

Raghavan’s research reveals that India’s ambassador to France DN Chatterjee began the process to get Israeli arms with a note to the external affairs ministry on July 6, 1971, saying assistance from Israel for “propaganda, finance and even procurement of armament and oil” would be “invaluable”.

Gandhi immediately accepted the proposal and through the country’s external intelligence agency R&AW began the process to get the arms through the tiny principality of Liechtenstein.

India didn’t have diplomatic ties with Israel at that time, having voted against its creation in 1948, and consistently supported the Arabs in the Israel-Palestine conflict.

Israel was in middle of an arms shortage but prime minister Golda Meir stepped in to divert arms meant for Iran to India. She sent a note addressed to Gandhi in Hebrew through Shlomo Zabuldowicz, the director of the firm handling the secret transfers, with a request for diplomatic ties in return for arms. The diplomatic ties, however, could only be established in 1992 when Narasimha Rao was the Indian PM.

Another note -- from then R&AW chief RN Kao on August 4, 1971 to Haksar — also finds mention in Raghavan’s book. The note detailed how the arms would be airlifted with a batch of Israeli instructors. The arms would eventually land up with the Indian Army and the Mukti Bahini, the guerilla force of Bengalis who would force the Pakistanis to surrender.

Other revelations in the book include a secret agreement between Iran and Pakistan to give air cover to Karachi in case of an Indian attack. But the Shah of Iran reneged on the agreement, fearing retaliation from the Soviet Union.

Interestingly, while Gandhi was worried about Chinese intervention, the then charge de affairs of the Indian embassy, Brajesh Mishra, who would go on to be the national security adviser in the Vajpayee government, sent an authoritative assessment that China would stay out of the war.

Finally, the US move to send in the seventh fleet to “intimidate” India proved counter-productive. As soon as the American ships arrived, India decided to step up the offensive and para-dropped troops in Tangail to make a dash for Dhaka. As the capital fell, India forced a surrender before any international power could intervene.
 
Israel has done lot more to India than the return favor - Israel helped India in Kargil war with crucial laser guided missiles which helped India use its Mirages to pin-pointedly strike the intruders. Also Israel provided Unmanned reconnaissance drones which helped India with vital intel in identifying the intruders among the rocks.
 
I have heard that Israel provided munitions during the 1965 war. I read it in a book actually. I can't verify it though.

But Israel is a country I admire, even though as of late, I disagree with their treatment of the palestinians and other issues.

I have alwys valued the Jewish intellectual tradition.
 
There's difference between a country helping another and a country buying military equipment from another country!
 
Two states helped India against Pakistan in 71.

USSR | We paid them back from 1979-1989
Israel | We paid them back in 1973 by helping the Arabs.

This should serve as a reminder to those in Pakistan who want to befriend Israel.

Trust me there aren't many who want to befriend Israel.
 
Two states helped India against Pakistan in 71.

USSR | We paid them back from 1979-1989
Israel | We paid them back in 1973 by helping the Arabs.

This should serve as a reminder to those in Pakistan who want to befriend Israel.
What about India? what the plan
 
Two states helped India against Pakistan in 71.

USSR | We paid them back from 1979-1989
Israel | We paid them back in 1973 by helping the Arabs.

This should serve as a reminder to those in Pakistan who want to befriend Israel.

I don't know why but still many of the Pakistanis tend to recall their blunders as one of their so called "heroic deeds". Many of the defence analysts both Pakistani as well as the independent ones that Pakistan aligning with US further to take an active part in the Cold War through its operations in Afghanistan against the USSR was one the greatest blunders that the Pakistani establishment ever did.

This blunder was an extension of your first major blunder, your continuous and unquestioning dependency of American support. Under Zia Ul Haq, you guys aligned with USA to create a civil war in its neighboring Afghanistan. Like Pakistan was to USA, Afghanistan was also a satellite state of USSR. It depended on it for money, military training and weapons. During that time, Mohammad Daoud Khan was the President of Afghanistan. He was a progressive politician who did a lot to support the rights of women and curb unemployment in his nation. When USSR betrayed Afghanistan and entered their forces in its boundary, Pakistan helped to train Jihadists in the tribal regions of Afghanistan and armed them to fight against USSR. This was basically a cold war between USA and USSR in which, Pakistan and Afghanistan were used as mere pawns. The two developing nations played their parts and today, the same Jihadists that had been trained by Pakistani Intelligence (ISI) have now turned their guns towards Pakistani military.

Zia Ul Haq knew that he cannot support a war against USSR merely on political basis. So he used the “cause for Islam” as a reason to gain the support of Pakistani citizens. Rapid Islamization followed and propaganda was used everywhere, from TV to Radio, from the homes of common people to the bunkers of Army soldiers. During all this, dollars flowed into the homes of the affluent and aristocrat in Pakistan, including the coffers of Zia Ul Haq and his aides.

Al-Qaeda and Taliban, the birth of all these terrorist groups can be traced back to that very decision of Zia Ul Haq, when he decided to support USA and wage a civil war in Afghanistan.

#That campaign was a disaster man; the consequences of which are still visible and will continue to be in the years to come......

#As you sow so shall you reap...
 
I don't know why but still many of the Pakistanis tend to recall their blunders as one of their so called "heroic deeds". Many of the defence analysts both Pakistani as well as the independent ones that Pakistan aligning with US further to take an active part in the Cold War through its operations in Afghanistan against the USSR was one the greatest blunders that the Pakistani establishment ever did.

This blunder was an extension of your first major blunder, your continuous and unquestioning dependency of American support. Under Zia Ul Haq, you guys aligned with USA to create a civil war in its neighboring Afghanistan. Like Pakistan was to USA, Afghanistan was also a satellite state of USSR. It depended on it for money, military training and weapons. During that time, Mohammad Daoud Khan was the President of Afghanistan. He was a progressive politician who did a lot to support the rights of women and curb unemployment in his nation. When USSR betrayed Afghanistan and entered their forces in its boundary, Pakistan helped to train Jihadists in the tribal regions of Afghanistan and armed them to fight against USSR. This was basically a cold war between USA and USSR in which, Pakistan and Afghanistan were used as mere pawns. The two developing nations played their parts and today, the same Jihadists that had been trained by Pakistani Intelligence (ISI) have now turned their guns towards Pakistani military.

Zia Ul Haq knew that he cannot support a war against USSR merely on political basis. So he used the “cause for Islam” as a reason to gain the support of Pakistani citizens. Rapid Islamization followed and propaganda was used everywhere, from TV to Radio, from the homes of common people to the bunkers of Army soldiers. During all this, dollars flowed into the homes of the affluent and aristocrat in Pakistan, including the coffers of Zia Ul Haq and his aides.

Al-Qaeda and Taliban, the birth of all these terrorist groups can be traced back to that very decision of Zia Ul Haq, when he decided to support USA and wage a civil war in Afghanistan.

#That campaign was a disaster man; the consequences of which are still visible and will continue to be in the years to come......

#As you sow so shall you reap...

Ah... i didnt read ur bs.. but Pakistan was already supporting the Afghan mujahideen before the americans came... so toodaloo...
 
There's difference between a country helping another and a country buying military equipment from another country!

As per the revelations Israel also provided India wholesome finance and that too I guess interest free in the same respect.......BTW no matter how they provided assistance to us by some or the other way; the sole beneficiary are our Bangladeshi brothers and sisters only.....
 
http://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/israel-helped-india-in-1971-war-book/article1-1146011.aspx

ndia may not have had diplomatic ties with Israel but New Delhi quietly sought and got arms from Tel Aviv as it prepared to go to war with Pakistan in 1971, a book has revealed.
The book, 1971, by scholar Srinath Raghavan offers fresh insights into the 14-day war that led to the creation of Bangladesh.

Raghavan accessed the PN Haksar papers maintained at the Nehru Memorial Museum and Library in Delhi. These papers document startling aspects of a war that is probably India’s finest military moment but has not been documented adequately. A diplomat, Haksar was also an adviser to the then Prime Minister Indira Gandhi.

Raghavan’s research reveals that India’s ambassador to France DN Chatterjee began the process to get Israeli arms with a note to the external affairs ministry on July 6, 1971, saying assistance from Israel for “propaganda, finance and even procurement of armament and oil” would be “invaluable”.

Gandhi immediately accepted the proposal and through the country’s external intelligence agency R&AW began the process to get the arms through the tiny principality of Liechtenstein.

India didn’t have diplomatic ties with Israel at that time, having voted against its creation in 1948, and consistently supported the Arabs in the Israel-Palestine conflict.

Israel was in middle of an arms shortage but prime minister Golda Meir stepped in to divert arms meant for Iran to India. She sent a note addressed to Gandhi in Hebrew through Shlomo Zabuldowicz, the director of the firm handling the secret transfers, with a request for diplomatic ties in return for arms. The diplomatic ties, however, could only be established in 1992 when Narasimha Rao was the Indian PM.

Another note -- from then R&AW chief RN Kao on August 4, 1971 to Haksar — also finds mention in Raghavan’s book. The note detailed how the arms would be airlifted with a batch of Israeli instructors. The arms would eventually land up with the Indian Army and the Mukti Bahini, the guerilla force of Bengalis who would force the Pakistanis to surrender.

Other revelations in the book include a secret agreement between Iran and Pakistan to give air cover to Karachi in case of an Indian attack. But the Shah of Iran reneged on the agreement, fearing retaliation from the Soviet Union.

Interestingly, while Gandhi was worried about Chinese intervention, the then charge de affairs of the Indian embassy, Brajesh Mishra, who would go on to be the national security adviser in the Vajpayee government, sent an authoritative assessment that China would stay out of the war.

Finally, the US move to send in the seventh fleet to “intimidate” India proved counter-productive. As soon as the American ships arrived, India decided to step up the offensive and para-dropped troops in Tangail to make a dash for Dhaka. As the capital fell, India forced a surrender before any international power could intervene.

So we used Jewish bullets on Pakistan army ...how low can we get???
 

Back
Top Bottom