What's new

Fatwa Chaos!

AgNoStiC MuSliM

ADVISORS
Joined
Jul 11, 2007
Messages
25,259
Reaction score
87
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
Muslim scholars decry ‘fatwa chaos’​

* Al-Azhar University churns out 1,000 fatwas a day
* Egyptian scholar says too many unqualified opinions being spread

Daily Times Monitor

LAHORE: Muslim scholars have condemned the explosion in the number of fatwas now being issued and called for the establishment of unified standards for pronouncing religious decrees.

Daniel Williams writes for Bloomberg News that a century ago, the fatwa department at Cairo’s Al-Azhar University issued fewer than 200 edicts a day. Now it turns out about 1,000.

“Around the world, an explosion in the number of fatwas is driving efforts by prominent Muslims to rein in the practice. That’s proving a nearly impossible task, given Islam’s decentralised nature and the growing number of outlets for the edicts,” says the report.

Muslims in Egypt seeking religious guidance may now turn to satellite television and the Internet for opinions from as far afield as Indonesia - unless they follow the fatwa issued in 2004 by the Dar ul-Ulum, India’s largest madrassa, that ruled Muslims shouldn’t watch TV.

Too many unqualified opinions: With no pope or patriarch to arbitrate orthodoxy, “it’s the nature of Islamic thought to have many options,” says Abdel Moti Bayoumi, who heads the Islamic Research Compilation Centre in Cairo. “But there are too many unqualified opinions being spread, and this is wrong.”

The result is what MENA, Egypt’s official news agency, calls “fatwa chaos”. Mainstream Islamic scholars blame TV and the Web for the proliferation of pronouncements. Confusing opinions are reaching millions of believers, these critics say.

Dissident preachers fault establishment clerics for issuing what they consider abstruse and sometimes ridiculous judgments.
Daily Times - Leading News Resource of Pakistan

A huge problem - perhaps a single body representative of each sect/sub sect within each country should be the only one to issue Fatwas's. Local Mullahs, scholars etc. could plead and argue their case in front of such bodies, give time for others to make counter arguments.
If I/m not mistaken, the CII in Pakistan is supposed to serve such a function. The trick is to get the majority of scholars on board and get people to understand that there is only one entity that they should follow in such matters.
 
Muslim clerics ban Quranic ringtones after Makkah meet RIYADH,

Nov 8 (AFP) - The Saudi-based Islamic Jurisprudence Council has banned the use of Quranic verses as mobile phone ringtones after a six-day meeting in the holy city of Makkah, a statement said on Thursday. “It is forbidden to use verses of the Holy Quran as mobile telephone ringtones because any such use would damage the holy Quran by their abrupt interruption of the psalm verses or by sounding in inappropriate places,” said the fatwa issued by the council. Around 70 Muslim clerics attended the meeting chaired by Saudi Arabia's grand mufti, Sheikh Abdelaziz Al-Sheikh, and held under the auspices of the Muslim World League. (Posted @ 18:18 PST)

Our clerics really need to take up some extra curricular activities (other than threatening people and announcing Jihad) to occupy their time. :disagree:

May I suggest organizing volunteers and going out and helping the poor, cleaning neighborhoods, helping poor neighborhoods with small house repairs etc....
 
is this really possible??? 1000 fatwas in a day!!!......i know the mullahs have been extraordinarily active in this department lately but this is hard to believe.

anyhow, the matter should be of grave concern to every muslim and the sooner it is dealt with the better.
 
Trying to find some funny Fatwa's:

- Rashad Hassan Khalil, former dean of Islamic law at al-Azhar University in Cairo, ruled in January 2006 that for married couples, “being completely naked during [the act] annuls the marriage.”

These two got a lot of attention, the second was rescinded I believe.

- Polio Vaccine: Pakistan’s largest Islamist umbrella group, the Muttahida Majlis-e-Amal (MMA), issued a fatwa in January 2007 endorsing the provincial government’s efforts to immunize children from polio in the country’s Northwest Frontier Province. But even though health workers carried copies of the ruling with them as they trudged across the province, The Guardian reported in February 2007 that the parents of some 24,000 children had refused to allow the workers to administer polio drops. It turns out that influential antistate clerics had been issuing their own fatwas denouncing the campaign as a Western plot to sterilize Muslims.

- Breast-feeding: Many Muslims believe that unmarried men and women should not work alone together—a stricture that can pose problems in today’s global economy. So one Islamic scholar came up with a novel solution: If a woman were to breast-feed her male colleague five times, the two could safely be alone together.

- In Iraq, Grand Ayatollah Al-Sistani, a prolific issuer of fatwas, declared that any Iraqi who did not vote for the United Shi’i Coalition list would be legally separated from his wife, and would also go to hell.

- In Bangladesh, the following was announced during Ramadan from a mosque microphone in the Haripur region: “No woman will be able to go to the market for shopping, and if any shopkeeper is found to sell goods to any woman, he will be fined 500 taka.” The fatwa resulted in losses for angry merchants.

- The Algerian militant Hassan Kattab, founder of the Group for Call and Combat, requested a fatwa from Saudi dignitaries that would enable him to sit down at negotiations with Algerian government authorities, whom he had previously declared impious.

- The Darul-Uloom Deoband, a 150-year-old Muslim seminary in India, ruled that a woman allegedly raped by her father-in-law would have to divorce her husband.

- In response to the question, “If a chicken defecates in my well, has [the water] become impure? How do I purify my well?” the Darul-Uloom Deoband — the same seminary that ruled on the alleged-rape case in India — answered: “Throw out 110 buckets of water from your well. Then it will be purified and the water can be used for wazu [washing before prayer].” (Commenting on a recent spate of ridiculous fatwas this fall, Indian journalist Saba Naqvi Bhaumik said, “Ask a stupid question, you get a stupid answer.”)

- “Soccer is Forbidden Except When Played as Training for Jihad.” This fatwa, translated into English this year and attributed to the Saudi Sheikh Abdallah Al-Najdi, was complemented by numerous directives, including: “One should not use the terminology established by the non-believers and the polytheists, like ‘foul,’ ‘penalty kick’... Whoever pronounces these terms should be punished, reprimanded, kicked out of the game, and should even be told in public: ‘You have come to resemble the non-believers and the polytheists, and this had been forbidden.’”
 
oh those crazy mullah's dont you just love them.
P.S i wanted to ask anyone here does anybody know how mosques are regulated by the government in pakistan
 
The Darul-Uloom Deoband, a 150-year-old Muslim seminary in India, ruled that a woman allegedly raped by her father-in-law would have to divorce her husband.

That stupid mullah who issued that fatwa had also asked her to marry her father-in-law. :crazy: That case had made headlines in every english newspaper in India.
 
Those Deobandis are really funny sometimes. Thankfully, the All India Muslim Law Board uses Hanafi laws.

According to me India should have a uniform civil code. Current Muslim laws in India are very harmful for the development of Muslim society in India.
 
Those Deobandis are really funny sometimes. Thankfully, the All India Muslim Law Board uses Hanafi laws.

According to me India should have a uniform civil code. Current Muslim laws in India are very harmful for the development of Muslim society in India.

When did u become the expert of Islamic Family Laws or you are just thinking these few fatwas from some quarter are the Muslim Family Laws. If you really want Uniform Civil Code you must first implement it for Hindus who are following unique customs from east to west and north to south.

By saying so you are playing with a issue a famous weapon of Fascist forces in India.
My one suggestion to you: If you want to know islam really you have a best opportunity in India itself. Just watch First India Islamic Satellite Channel:
The Peace TV (Also the Website: PEACE TV).
 
Yes Ababel i agree with you :)


and for Mr Stealth Deoband is still considered to be authntic to quote.

So please if you do not know anything about Islam do not comment
 
The Darul-Uloom Deoband, a 150-year-old Muslim seminary in India, ruled that a woman allegedly raped by her father-in-law would have to divorce her husband.

These **** azz are telling the victim what to do.what about the guy who rapped her.:hitwall:

Uneducated peoples issuing a fatwa excellent.:enjoy:
 
When did u become the expert of Islamic Family Laws or you are just thinking these few fatwas from some quarter are the Muslim Family Laws. If you really want Uniform Civil Code you must first implement it for Hindus who are following unique customs from east to west and north to south.

By saying so you are playing with a issue a famous weapon of Fascist forces in India.
My one suggestion to you: If you want to know islam really you have a best opportunity in India itself. Just watch First India Islamic Satellite Channel:
The Peace TV (Also the Website: PEACE TV).

Hindus already have uniform civil code all across India.

Also, true secularism implies equal civil rights for all, including rights to marriage, divorce, inheritance and property. The muslim civil laws in India don't provide for all this.

So, uniform civil code isn't a fascist concept, but the lack of a civil code is an instrument of division in the country. It is also one of the reasons why muslims lag in development.
 
Hindus already have uniform civil code all across India.

Also, true secularism implies equal civil rights for all, including rights to marriage, divorce, inheritance and property. The muslim civil laws in India don't provide for all this.

So where are all these equal rights for all in India.

Howcome a Dalit can not marry someone from high cast Hindu family secularism implies equal civil rights for all???/
 
So where are all these equal rights for all in India.

Howcome a Dalit can not marry someone from high cast Hindu family secularism implies equal civil rights for all???/

Huh? Of course they can. If a dalit wants to marry a higher caste there is no law to prevent that from happening. .

Also, Uniform Civil Code is recommended by the Constitution of India. It has not been implemented yet because the various religions haven't been able to reach an agreement on the details of the code. Hopefully it will happen some time in the future.
 
Ababeel and Jana,
Learn to differentiate between Personal Law and customs. Two entirely different concepts. Hindus have a variety of different customs across India but all are subject to the same common persona laws. All muslims in India have a different set of personal laws because they wanted them to be different. For example a muslim woman in India still does not have the right to demand divorce from her husband while her husband can take a divorce by just saying 'Talaq' thrice. This is one of a few pathetic medieval laws followed only by the muslims in India again because they want to. They haven't been forced. This is what stealth assasin was referring to when he stressed the need for a uniform civil code to be applicable to all people regardless of religion.
 

Back
Top Bottom